Nightsong
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
ME Action put out this newsletter yesterday:
https://mailchi.mp/meaction/why-the-press-wants-to-talk-with-meaction
(Yes, some viruses like HIV can alter host expression of various different matrix metalloproteinases, and cytokine release can also result in the upregulation of various MMPs. Some bacteria can make collagenases, although viruses can't. But all of that is a long way from "trigger EDS".)
Getting nonsense into National Geographic is not something to be proud of. Is there an advocacy organisation or charity that does have sensible views these days?
https://mailchi.mp/meaction/why-the-press-wants-to-talk-with-meaction
Our staff has spent hours educating journalists about ME and infection-associated diseases in general through a range of topics ranging from research funding for Long COVID; to why viruses can trigger EDS or make it worse; and how the presidential candidates are ignoring the disability community.
National Geographic wrote an excellent article about why infections, like COVID-19, can trigger or worsen EDS, as infections can damage connective tissue. #MEAction’s Jaime Seltzer spoke with the reporter about the science behind this, as many people living with ME also have EDS.
Needless to say this is gibberish. Most forms of EDS are Mendelian. And regardless of whether you think that polygenic hypermobility should be classified as EDS III or not there is also no evidence of viruses causing or worsening EDS in this way. And, finally, it is simply wrong: viruses can't make collagenases.“The viruses themselves will make collagenase, which is the enzyme that breaks down collagen. There’s the potential for [someone with a collagen disorder] to be more susceptible to an infection-associated chronic illness.”
- Jaime Seltzer, #MEAction Scientific Director
(Yes, some viruses like HIV can alter host expression of various different matrix metalloproteinases, and cytokine release can also result in the upregulation of various MMPs. Some bacteria can make collagenases, although viruses can't. But all of that is a long way from "trigger EDS".)
Getting nonsense into National Geographic is not something to be proud of. Is there an advocacy organisation or charity that does have sensible views these days?
Last edited: