There are too many good ones to single out, it's worth reading the thread. Surprisingly the usual friends-of-Sharpe and sock puppets aren't in the likes. A few tweets noted that Discus comments weren't approved and some excuse was given that this was just a preview, which is irrelevant. BMJ folks just stopped responding. I noticed another tweet from them about the preview status: Could be worth doing an official S4ME response. Question is who has the energy for it. I may give it a try once the full article but I'm not convinced anything going against Sharpe's narrative would be approved. It's clearly a circle jerk where dissent isn't allowed.