Advice on mask-wearing to protect against Covid-19

As reported on The Guardian website today, The Royal Society for Data Evaluation and Learning for Viral Epidemics (DELVE) has just published a report which comes out in favour of face masks being worn by the general public:

Face Masks for the General Public

Summary

Face masks could offer an important tool for contributing to the management of community transmission of Covid19 within the general population. Evidence supporting their potential effectiveness comes from analysis of: (1) the incidence of asymptomatic and pre-symptomatic transmission; (2) the role of respiratory droplets in transmission, which can travel as far as 1-2 meters; and (3) studies of the use of homemade and surgical masks to reduce droplet spread. Our analysis suggests that their use could reduce onward transmission by asymptomatic and pre-symptomatic wearers if widely used in situations where physical distancing is not possible or predictable, contrasting to the standard use of masks for the protection of wearers. If correctly used on this basis, face masks, including homemade cloth masks, can contribute to reducing viral transmission.

https://rs-delve.github.io/reports/2020/05/04/face-masks-for-the-general-public.html
 
Coronavirus: hamster research shows effectiveness of masks ‘huge’ in Covid-19 battle, Hong Kong scientists say

"Hamsters placed in adjoining cages with infected subjects were infected at a 66.7 per cent rate; the introduction of a barrier saw the percentage drop to 16.7‘

It shows very clearly that if infected hamsters or humans … put on masks, they actually protect other people,’ HKU’s Dr Yuen Kwok-yung says"

Edit: I was wondering how they made hamsters wearing masks, but it went like this:


"in their experiment, partitions made of surgical masks were set up between cages in an isolated facility, with an infected hamster on one side, and three healthy hamsters on the other. A fan was then placed in between to make sure the virus would “transmit” between cages."

So transmission might drop even more with a close fitted mask on the face?
 
Last edited:
'UK Government announces massive hamster cull' as research suggests they are a massive factor in the transmission of covid-19 due to them not wearing masks, or following social distancing rules.
Why has no one warned us that rodents can transmit covid-19?

We're surrounded by rodents.

I seem to misremember that no one in the UK is more than 2 meters from a rodent at all times, on average.
 
Has anyone determined yet the minimum safe distance to be away from someone without a mask who is talking to you? I just made the mistake of going outside and encountering a neighbour who wanted to talk to me, at length. Managed a good twelve feet, mostly, but we were having to speak correspondingly louder...

I've noticed that discipline seems to have broken down on social distancing in a lot of people on the street, where I briefly ventured (and wish I hadn't)...
 
Apparently the thinking is now that you're unlikely to catch it from someone else in the open air just by walking past them - could that be a contributing factor?
 
The World Health Organisation have updated their guidance on face masks for members of the public:

WHO advises public to wear face masks when unable to distance

People over 60 or with health issues should wear a medical-grade mask when they are out and cannot socially distance, according to new guidance from the World Health Organization, while all others should wear a three-layer fabric mask.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/05/who-changes-advice-medical-grade-masks-over-60s
 
So, does anyone have tips for how to choose from the many different brands of disposable masks online? Thanks!

Edit: Looking to buy some disposable "medical grade" masks, just in case we ever need them, and I'm not even sure what "medical grade" means.
 
Last edited:
When WHO say “medical masks“ for those over 60/vulnerable to illness, do they mean “surgical masks“?

Yes. This is the WHO definition of a medical mask from their latest guidance document regarding this (published 5th June):

Definitions

Medical masks are defined as surgical or procedure masks that are flat or pleated; they are affixed to the head with straps that go around the ears or head or both. Their performance characteristics are tested according to a set of standardized test methods (ASTM F2100, EN 14683, or equivalent) that aim to balance high filtration, adequate breathability and optionally, fluid penetration resistance.(34, 35)

Filtering facepiece respirators (FFR), or respirators, similarly offer a balance of filtration and breathability; however, whereas medical masks filter 3 micrometre droplets, respirators must filter more challenging 0.075 micrometre solid particles. European FFRs, according to standard EN 149, at FFP2 performance filter at least 94% solid NaCl particles and oil droplets, and US N95 FFRs, according to NIOSH 42 CFR Part 84, filter at least 95% NaCl particles. Certified FFRs must also ensure unhindered breathing with maximum resistances during inhalation and exhalation. Another important difference is the way filtration is tested; medical mask filtration tests are performed on a cross- section of the masks whereas FFRs are tested for filtration across the entire surface. Therefore, the layers of the filtration material and the FFR shape, ensuring outer edges of the FFR seal around wearer’s face, result in a guaranteed claimed filtration when worn compared to the open shape, or leaking structure, of medical masks. Other FFR performance requirements include being within specified parameters for maximum CO2 build up, total inward leakage and tensile strength of straps.(36, 37)

https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/1279750/retrieve
 
So, does anyone have tips for how to choose from the many different brands of disposable masks online? Thanks!

Edit: Looking to buy some disposable "medical grade" masks, just in case we ever need them, and I'm not even sure what "medical grade" means.

Hi @ahimsa - see above the answer to your question about medical masks. I can’t advise about brands but it’s important to make sure that the face mask carries the appropriate certification. The following advice is also from the WHO document I posted above:

Medical masks should be certified according to international or national standards to ensure they offer predictable product performance when used by health workers, according to the risk and type of procedure performed in a health care setting. Designed for single use, a medical mask’s initial filtration (at least 95% droplet filtration), breathability and, if required, fluid resistance are attributed to the type (e.g. spunbond or meltblown) and layers of manufactured non-woven materials (e.g. polypropylene, polyethylene or cellulose). Medical masks are rectangular in shape and comprise three or four layers. Each layer consists of fine to very fine fibres. These masks are tested for their ability to block droplets (3 micrometres in size; EN 14683 and ASTM F2100 standards) and particles (0.1 micrometre in size; ASTM F2100 standard only). The masks must block droplets and particles while at the same time they must also be breathable by allowing air to pass. Medical masks are regulated medical devices and categorized as PPE.
 
I am not sure, but I assume that if you purchase your masks from a registered pharmacy then they would only be supplying brands that have the correct certification. Currently, that is comparatively expensive to do in the UK, compared to sourcing them from Ebay or Amazon, which may be an indicator that many brands do not meet the high medical standard required for full PPE.
 
Yeah the box of surgical masks I got before are from some random seller on eBay. I don’t think they have any certification.
 
Seems like some familiar names are against wearing masks
Free entertainment from those clowns again. Clare Geralda complaining about someone being patronising, SW complaining about someone being over-certain and unquestioning. I'm going to have to start ordering my irony meters in bulk if they carry on like this.

Where are Sharpe and White? They can usually be relied upon to put their feet in it on Twitter at a time like this. Most disappointing.
 
Seems like some familiar names are against wearing masks
Good. I encourage the pair of them to go on acting in public like the arrogant entitled reckless arse-clowns they really are. The more of it their non-psych colleagues in the UK see, the sooner they will shove them aside.

And don't you just love Wessely lecturing others about the importance of rigorous science being done to establish the facts before making a policy or clinical recommendation. Does this guy possess any sense of self-reflection & humility at all?
 
Back
Top Bottom