Who is Simon Wessely?

Eagles said:
You can listen to the interview at
Click to expand...
Thanks @Eagles !

Having listened to the interview, I find the quote to be less controversial than I imagined it at first. I suspect there isn't much difference for treatment if the trigger of your ME/CFS was EBV or cytomegalovirus or something else. So that doctors focus on managing current symptoms is probably normal. It's because Wessely has an unrealistic view on the possibility of rehabilitation through CBT, that the quote sounds controversial.
 
"We’re not going to go doing more and more tests to find out what was the virus because, frankly, even if we found it there's nothing we're going to do about it. We're in the business of rehabilitation."
Click to expand...

Basically, "you got the flu so what, its gone now and you are malingering. Do our CBT and GET rehab and you will be cured of your faulty illness beliefs and deconditioning".
 
Last edited:
large donner said:
Basically, "you got the flu so what, its gone now and you are malingering. Do our CBT and GET rehab and you will be cured of your faulty illness beliefs and deconditioning".
Click to expand...

I think it's a bad idea to use to term 'malingering' when putting forth the views of those who have not used that term.
 
"We’re not going to go doing more and more tests to find out what was the virus because, frankly, even if we found it, there's nothing we're going to do about it. We're in the business of rehabilitation."
Click to expand...

Needless to say, they should be in the business of doing everything they can think of to try to falsify their hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
Forbin said:
Needless to say, they should be in the business of doing everything they can think of to try to falsify their hypothesis.
Click to expand...
But they already looked under the streetlight. Surely you can't expect them to look any further? The streetlight is right there and just way more cozy than the darkness out there. There is nothing outside the cavern and the shadows on the wall are the only reality.

1-x59cvjb_mojtouxmkbihsq.jpeg
 
large donner said:
Its not a bad idea you just think it is.
Click to expand...

You think it's a good idea?

I think it's unethical when Wessely and co try to make patients seem worse than they are, and the same is true if anyone does the same to Wessely.

Also, it harms attempts to draw attention to real problems with their work, allowing them to present their critics as either ill-informed or else deceptive.

Here's Wessely doing just that:

When people are not careful with their criticisms it makes it easier for Wessely to get away with the mistreatment of patients.
 
Last edited:
Esther12 said:
You think it's a good idea?

I think it's unethical when Wessely and co try to make patients seem worse than they are, and the same is true if anyone does the same to Wessely.

Also, it harms attempts to draw attention to real problems with their work, allowing them to present their critics as either ill-informed or else deceptive.

Here's Wessely doing just that:

When people are not careful with their criticisms it makes it easier for Wessely to get away with the mistreatment of patients.
Click to expand...


This is my post in full @Esther12.....

Basically, "you got the flu so what, its gone now and you are malingering. Do our CBT and GET rehab and you will be cured of your faulty illness beliefs and deconditioning".
Click to expand...

Its clearly me paraphrasing if you read it properly as indicated by the fact that the whole statement is in inverted comas.

You are the one now bringing it to everyone's attention aligning it to Wessely as if I claimed it to be a direct quote.

Perhaps you shouldn't do that if you are so concerned about that issue.
 
How are we to know what he thinks or doesn't think?

It's a question of what the reasonable person might reasonably infer from his words, taking into account the circumstances in which they are uttered or written. He is able by his conduct to affect and alter such inferences.
 
large donner said:
This is my post in full @Esther12.

Its clearly me paraphrasing if you bother to read it properly as indicated by the fact that the whole statement is in inverted comas.

You are the one now bringing it to everyone's attention aligning it to Wessely as if I claimed it to be a direct quote.

Perhaps you shouldn't do that if you are so concerned about that issue.
Click to expand...

I read what you said and followed the discussion fine. I respondedg to your paraphrasing by saying "I think it's a bad idea to use to term 'malingering' when putting forth the views of those who have not used that term."

Then when you disagreed with my point I tried to explain why I thought it was valid, using an example of Wessely complaining about being falsely ascribed views about malingering. I never said that your comment claimed it was a direct quote - it clearly was not.

I think that there is a danger that if other patients were to trust your re-interpretation of Wessely's words, and allowed that to influence the claims they made to others, this could be harmful and encourage the view that patient critics of Wessely's work are unreasonable.
 
Esther12 said:
I read what you said and followed the discussion fine. I respondedg to your paraphrasing by saying "I think it's a bad idea to use to term 'malingering' when putting forth the views of those who have not used that term."



I think that there is a danger that if other patients were to trust your re-interpretation of Wessely's words,
Click to expand...

So within two sentences you go from realising it was paraphrasing to calling it "my reinterpretation of his words?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
large donner said:
So within two sentences you go from realising it was paraphrasing to calling it "my reinterpretation of his words?
Click to expand...

I thought your attempted paraphrasing was an unhelpful reinterpretation of his words, and I've already tried to explain why.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@Esther12 dont let Wessely gaslight you will his faux outrage. By falling for that you are allowing him to shut down the numerous ways people point out his ludicrousness including using satirical paraphrasing.

Look at post 9 in this thread from rvallee the comment and the cartoon. Do you think that's a claim that Wessely is looking for wallets under streetlights? Why not issue one of your warnings on that post too?
 
It's not about falling for being gaslighted, it's about trying to learn from problems of the past. The cartoon doesn't play into the prejudices that are used to dismiss patients - acting as if Wessely views CFS patients as malingers when he has not said that does, even if it's intended to be a form of satire.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom