Unrest - reviews and general articles

Last edited:
Sly Saint said:
Another good review:
"A Film on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome That Tells a Story We Don’t Normally Hear
By eth | March 8, 2018
A Film on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome That Tells a Story We Don’t Normally HearBeyond the candy fluff of ‘Women’s Day’, Unrest raises the bar for feminists, disability rights activists and their allies."

http://ethforex.info/2018/03/08/a-f...ome-that-tells-a-story-we-dont-normally-hear/
Click to expand...
Thanks for posting. I enjoyed feeling the author’s high energy level as I read her words; she holds nothing back. Ms Salelkar delivers a few good punches, and also clarifies the challenges of what it’s like to live with a disability. If given the opportunity, I would not hesitate to hire her as my attorney!
 
MeSci said:
"In Denmark, symptoms of ME are misdiagnosed as a mental illness and persons are institutionalised under mental health laws."

It happens in the UK too...

:emoji_cry:
Click to expand...

It’s still so difficult for me to comprehend this atrocity. It must be expensive for a government to cover the costs of institutionalizing someone? So it doesn’t sound like it’s a decision based upon cost? Isn’t it cheaper to do nothing at all, and let the patient live at home, and offer no treatments?

It’s all so puzzling to me; it makes no sense at all. No one gains and everyone looses.

I am glad Unrest touched upon this, but I didn’t walk away with any logical explanations as to why this barbaric practice continues.
 
Sly Saint said:
yes, something I have pointed out to those who have seen the film and commented on 'what's happening in Denmark?"
The most widely 'publicised' case here was Sophia Mirza and suggest anyone who finds similar comments on twitter or FB link to it.
http://www.sophiaandme.org.uk/
Click to expand...

It’s almost as if, sweeping ME patients under the rug, is a way to keep them from exposing the truth about PACE. It’s seems to be more of a form of harassment or punishment, to keep them silenced, and it’s even more of a future threat that could be used to remind them, what will happen if they ever chose to go public (again).

ME also seems to be a reminder of the failures of medicine; and the truth can be threatening.

It’s as if having ME is a crime, and punishment is well deserved and issued.

I am hoping Unrest2 will cover more in-depth the reasons behind all of this.

Yes, my friends too, after viewing Unrest, they couldn’t understand why it’s a crime to have ME in Denmark? I told them it’s not just Denmark.
 
Last edited:
MErmaid said:
It’s still so difficult for me to comprehend this atrocity. It must be expensive for a government to cover the costs of institutionalizing someone? So it doesn’t sound like it’s a decision based upon cost? Isn’t it cheaper to do nothing at all, and let the patient live at home, and offer no treatments?

It’s all so puzzling to me; it makes no sense at all. No one gains and everyone looses.
Click to expand...
A certain level of tolerance and even encouragement of the psychosomatic paradigm is beneficial for government entities. But some of the people creating and selling those theories are true believers, rather than just savvy salesman. When those true believers are given too much power, they ceasing being beneficial even to politicians and government agencies - but the damage is still done.

The only good thing about such extremism is that it forces the cynical and self-interested promoters of the psychosomatic paradigm to withdraw their public support of those actions. They becomes a liability and an embarrassment, and the fundamentalist believers are eventually hung out to dry. This is why Crawley has never been as much of a destructive force as Simon Wessely, for example - her beliefs drive her to do stupid things, whereas Wessely carefully uses the same paradigm as a convenient way in which to advance his own career.

I suspect Per Fink's influence is disappearing, even if no one in power has officially denounced him or his actions. The public outcry is too damaging to various reputations for it to be allowed to happen again.
 
Last edited:
I'm so glad that we are finally seeing some research that includes the severely and very severely ill, and we need more if that cruel abuse of very sick ME patients is to be stopped.
 
perspective1231mag.jpg


Is there anyone else (apart from me) who thinks this is a very weird picture? It really looks (in parts) as if someone has decided to check the health of Brea's hair.
 
@Arnie Pye I used google to search for EEG photos and quickly found this page with a similar photo:

https://thelizarmy.com/2011/02/from-beginning-to-end-this-was-my-eeg-experience/

Of course, her photo is not in the same league as Jen's when it comes to the quality of photo (composition, lighting, etc.).

I think it makes sense that as Jen's film got closer to completion there would be some professional photographers taking really good photos that would show the difficulties of diagnosing ME / living with ME but at the same time still look good on a movie poster.
 
Missed this one:
Radio times:
"
by David Parkinson

Often dismissed as a psychosomatic condition, chronic fatigue syndrome (or myalgic encephalomyelitis) afflicts 17 million people worldwide and, according to 30-something Jennifer Brea's pulverisingly frank documentary, 85% of them are women.

Home movies reveal how dynamic Brea was before a fever triggered debilitating symptoms that transformed her life. But, as the self-filmed footage of her attacks shows, Brea can be reduced to a state of excruciating helplessness that she discovers from online research is also experienced by Jessica Taylor in Kent, Lee-Ray Denton in Georgia and Whitney Dafoe in California.

The latter is the bedridden son of Ron Davis, who is one of the shockingly few scientists researching the ailment, along with Nancy Klimas, who provides several invaluably accessible insights in seeking to confound Dane Per Fink, whose refusal to accept the physical aspects of ME has shaped the country's approach to sufferers like Karina Hansen, who spent three years in psychiatric care.

Brea certainly puts on a brave face in exposing her travails. But there's no self-pity in this admirable plea for medical science to take this cruel illness and its "missing millions" seriously."

http://www.radiotimes.com/film/fs24k4/
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom