News from Germany

5001st time might be the charm! Literally the same junk, presented as innovative, as is tradition. You'd think failure is almost an addiction here.

Country promotes model project for seriously ill adults after infections

People who suffer from severe physical impairments after infection should be better cared for in the future. The Ministry of Social Affairs is supporting a model project with around 400,000 euros.
...
The project “Health care Baden-Württemberg for adults with severe functional restrictions in the context of post-acute infection syndromes (SEVERE-PAIS)” runs from 1. November 2025 to 31. May 2027 and is headed by the Department of General Practice and Health Research of the University of Heidelberg under the direction of the Medical Director Prof. Dr. med. Attila Altiner performed.
...
With the project “SEVERE-PAIS” two innovative supply approaches are now being tested and scientifically accompanied:
  • Telemedicine care/multi-professional online support offer : For six months, regular medical visits, psychotherapeutic support and visits are carried out by so-called PAIS-Nurses – each via video consultations. GPs are involved in demand-oriented manner via case meetings. A total of 15 patients are treated.
  • Seeking care: A multi-professional team visits those affected directly at home to provide medical and psychotherapeutic support on site. Regular medical visits and visits by a PAIS-Nurse as well as a psychotherapeutic online support are also carried out over a period of six months. Here, too, GPs are involved in a needs-based manner via case meetings and 15 patients are cared for.
Both approaches are intended to show which form best meets the needs of the seriously ill. Overall, 30 particularly severely affected patients benefit directly from the project.
 
AI translation:

The Parliamentary Committee of Inquiry on “Review of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Lessons for Future Pandemic Events” unanimously decided in its 3rd meeting on 22 September 2025 to hold a public hearing on 10 November 2025 from 2 to 6 p.m. on the topic:

“Protecting Vulnerable Populations and Addressing Long-Term Consequences (Long COVID / Post-Vac)”

https://www.bundestag.de/mediathek/live

Deutscher Bundestag Enquete-Kommission „Aufarbeitung der Corona-Pandemie und Lehren für zukünftige pandemische Ereignisse"


Liste der Sachverständigen
Öffentliche Anhörung am Montag, 10. November 2025, 14.00 Uhr


Holger Lange'
Abteilungsleiter der Bundesrechtsabteilung des „Sozialverbands VdK Deutschland e.V."

Elena Lierck'
Gründerin von „NichtGenesenKids e.V."

Ricarda Piepenhagen'
Gründerin von „NichtGenesen"

Prof. Dr. med. Carmen Scheibenbogen' Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin, stellvertretende Leiterin des Instituts für Medizinische Immunologie, Leiterin des Arbeitsbereichs Immundefekte und Postinfektiöse Erkrankungen
Vertreterin/Vertreter des Bundesvereins Impfgeschädigter e.V.'

Eva-Maria Welskop-Deffaa'
Präsidentin des Deutschen Caritasverbandes e.V.

'Fraktionsubergreifend zur öffentlichen Anhörung eingeladen.
 
Here’s an AI Summary of today’s Bundestag hearing:

Short Summary: The Neglected Crisis of ME/CFS

This summary focuses on the topic of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) as discussed during the hearing.

Inadequate Healthcare and Stigmatization

The healthcare situation for patients with post-infectious syndromes like Long Covid, ME/CFS, and Post-Vac is dire. Professor Dr. Carmen Scheibenbogen from Charité Berlin highlights that these conditions are often neglected in medical training, leading to a lack of expertise among physicians and a scarcity of specialized outpatient clinics. This results in patients frequently facing disbelief and stigma, with a recent study showing that 80% of Long Covid and Post-Vac patients report experiences of stigmatization. The prevailing misconception is that these complex physical illnesses can be adequately treated with psychotherapy or rehabilitation, which ignores the severe physical limitations of the sufferers.

The Plight of Children and Adolescents

An estimated 90,000 to 140,000 children and adolescents in Germany suffer from Long Covid, Post-Vac, and ME/CFS, often triggered by infections like COVID-19 or Epstein-Barr virus. Elena Lierk, founder of "Nicht-Genesen-Kids e.V.", shares the story of her own daughter, who has been severely ill with ME/CFS for five years. Families are often left alone to navigate the difficult path to a diagnosis, facing ridicule, stigmatization, and even accusations of child welfare endangerment from doctors and authorities. The lack of understanding and appropriate medical care means many affected children can no longer attend school, and their condition often deteriorates due to ignorance and mismanagement.

Economic Impact and Call for Research Funding

The societal costs of Long Covid and ME/CFS are immense, estimated at 60 billion euros for the year 2024 alone, which is 1.5% of Germany's GDP. Ricarda Piepenhagen, founder of the patient organization "Nicht Genesen," emphasizes that this is not a past issue but an ongoing health crisis, with more than 1.5 million people affected in Germany. Despite promising university-led research into treatments like immunoadsorption to remove autoantibodies, progress is stalled due to a lack of funding. Experts and patient advocates are urgently calling for a "Decade against Long Covid and ME/CFS," demanding sustained financial investment in research to develop effective treatments and provide hope for the hundreds of thousands who are severely ill and unable to participate in life.

Attached the full subtitles in german and a long summary in English (AI got slightly confused with the timestamps near the end due to the 3h length).
 

Attachments

30min podcast on ME/CFS and Long COVID on SWR:

Full transcript in German: link

This is an AI summary of the podcast "The Expensive Epidemic – How Long Covid and ME/CFS Burden Society."

An Invisible Illness​

Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) is a severe, physical illness with no known cure. It often begins after a viral infection, such as the flu, Epstein-Barr virus, or COVID-19. Those affected suffer from extreme exhaustion, where simple activities like grocery shopping or having a conversation can require days or weeks of recovery. Many are unable to work, meet friends, or participate in life, spending their days at home on the sofa or in bed. Despite being recognized by the World Health Organization (WHO) since 1969, the disease remains poorly understood and researched.

The Story of a Young Patient​

The podcast tells the story of Jano, who fell ill with ME/CFS at the age of 21 after a viral infection. His mother, Daniela Binder, describes how her once athletic and energetic son, who was about to start a career as a media designer, became progressively weaker. His initial symptoms included flu-like feelings, tinnitus, blurred vision, "brain fog," and widespread pain. After a rehabilitation program that was too strenuous for him, his condition worsened dramatically, leaving him completely bedridden in a dark, quiet room, unable to tolerate any light, sound, or social interaction.

A Pandemic After the Pandemic​

In the spring of 2025, the ME/CFS Research Foundation calculated that over 1.5 million people in Germany suffer from Long COVID or ME/CFS. An estimated two-thirds of them are unable to work or attend school, and a quarter are bedridden. The study, conducted with the risk assessment company Risklayer, estimated the economic cost of these illnesses in Germany for the year 2024 to be 63.1 billion euros. This figure is comparable to the annual budget for the German military or the entire operation of the Deutsche Bahn.

Complex Symptoms and Diagnostic Hurdles​

Long COVID and ME/CFS present with over 200 different symptoms, making them highly complex and individualized. Patients may experience muscle pain, migraine-like headaches, breathing difficulties, speech problems, tingling sensations, dizziness, hair loss, rapid heartbeat, and severe cognitive impairments known as "brain fog." Dr. Natalie Grams, a physician who is herself affected, describes this as a fog in the brain that makes it impossible to hold onto thoughts. Diagnosing the illness is a process of elimination, as doctors must rule out other conditions like heart muscle inflammation, depression, or multiple sclerosis.

Potential Biological Causes​

While not fully understood, research provides clues about the underlying pathology. Professor Carmen Scheibenbogen, an immunologist at the Charité in Berlin, explains that some patients show signs of persistent low-grade inflammation in their blood and tissues, including blood vessels and nerve cells. Another key finding is the presence of auto-antibodies, which are antibodies that mistakenly attack the body's own tissues. In ME/CFS, these may damage the autonomic nervous system, which controls functions like heart rate, breathing, and blood distribution, explaining why patients' muscles and brains may not receive proper blood flow during exertion.

Lack of Funding and Recognition​

Despite the high number of patients and enormous costs, there is a significant lack of acceptance and funding for ME/CFS and Long COVID. Former Health Minister Karl Lauterbach states that the government has failed this large group of suffering individuals. He notes that at least one billion euros are needed for research in Germany, yet in 2025, the government is only spending about 15 million euros. The pharmaceutical industry shows little interest because the drugs that might be repurposed are often already on the market and cannot be sold at high prices, and the basic research required is considered high-risk.

A Broken System for Patients​

Patients face immense struggles within the healthcare system. They are often not taken seriously by medical professionals, who may dismiss their physical symptoms as psychological. Rehabilitation programs designed for general recovery can be harmful for ME/CFS patients, leading to severe relapses, or "crashes." Patients and their families often have to pay for treatments themselves and struggle to get support for things like transportation to medical appointments, as these are not covered for ME/CFS in the way they are for other serious illnesses like cancer.
 

Another article about AmRe-LoCO:

Hesse Supports Long Covid Care: New Treatment Concept Tested

Pilot Project in Lahn-Dill District

A pilot project called AmRe-LoCO has begun in the Lahn-Dill district to improve care for people affected by Post Covid and strengthen research. The project combines local therapies, digital services, and scientific monitoring. It includes physiotherapy, psychotherapy, rehabilitation sports, and self-help groups, complemented by online modules such as exercise programs, relaxation strategies, cognitive training, and video consultations. All activities are coordinated through a telemedicine platform, allowing flexible use from home. Special guides support and advise patients, while general practitioners receive training to recognize Long Covid earlier and provide targeted help.

Funding and Political Commitment
The state of Hesse has funded the project with a total of 1.2 million euros up to 2025. Health Minister Diana Stolz (CDU) announced an additional 500,000 euros for the following year, despite the challenging budget situation.

A Societal Issue
Stolz described the illness as a “societal issue” requiring broad cooperation to research, diagnose, and treat effectively. Diagnosis can be difficult and lengthy, and more understanding is needed for people suffering from Long Covid or chronic fatigue syndrome. She emphasized raising public awareness and preventing stigmatization of those affected.

Role of Research and Federal Support
The Post-Covid Coordination Office at the privatized University Hospital Gießen and Marburg, funded by Hesse with 145,000 euros annually, plays a key role in advancing care research to use resources more effectively. At the federal level, new funding and guidelines have been introduced to improve care for Long Covid patients step by step.
 
Medical-scientific hybrid half-day congress about FAME for physicians, researchers, as well as patients, relatives, and other interested parties on Friday, November 28, 2025:

REGISTRATION

HALF-DAY CONGRESS FAME

Functional Autoantibodies against G Protein-Coupled Receptors in Individuals with ME/CFS

Medical-scientific hybrid half-day congress
for physicians, researchers, as well as patients, relatives, and other interested parties

Friday, November 28, 2025
Admission from 12:00 p.m.
Lecture Hall, Head Clinics (Ernst Freiberger Sr. Lecture Hall), Schwabachanlage 6, 91054 Erlangen
or online via Zoom Webinar

Organizer: University Hospital Erlangen
No participation fee, CME credits available for medical professionals https://creventtool.de/anmeldung.php?event=79

More information about FAME:
Functional Autoantibodies against G Protein-Coupled Receptors in Individuals with ME/CFS

Welcome to the information page for our research project FAME – Functional Autoantibodies against G Protein-Coupled Receptors in Individuals with ME/CFS.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, also known as Myalgic Encephalomyelitis / Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS), is a complex, multisystemic disease characterized by extreme exhaustion, cognitive impairments, and dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system. Despite the large number of people affected, the causes of the disease remain incompletely understood. Our project “FAME” aims to address this gap by generating new insights and developing innovative diagnostic approaches.


What is it about?​

The project investigates whether functional autoantibodies against G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR-fAAb) play a role in the development of ME/CFS.
Initial findings, including from Post-COVID studies, suggest that these antibodies may contribute to circulatory disturbances in the brain and eyes.
Since ME/CFS symptoms are often of post-infectious origin, the project focuses on exploring connections between infections, the formation of autoantibodies, and the onset of the disease.


What is the goal?​

The main objective of FAME is to gain a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms of ME/CFS and to identify new biomarkers that can enable earlier diagnosis and more personalized therapy.


How will this be done?​

Within the project, we systematically collect and analyze clinical measurement data from individuals affected by ME/CFS.
Modern technologies are employed to uncover the molecular mechanisms involved and to identify correlations between symptoms and potential biomarkers.

(Logo of the Federal Ministry for Research, Technology and Space Flight)


Who leads the study and how is it funded?​

The interdisciplinary team, led by PD Dr. Dr. Bettina Hohberger from the Department of Ophthalmology at University Hospital Erlangen, is conducting the study between 2024 and 2027.
The project is supported by the Federal Ministry for Research, Technology and Space Flight (BMFTR). https://www.augenklinik.uk-erlangen.de/forschung/ag-long-covid-me/cfs/fame/
 
This document about a panel decision to not recommend funding a phase 2b Inebilizumab (Uplizna) trial was obtained by an FOI request to the German Ministry of Education.

1000085920.jpg

Source:
 
Last edited:
Good report on RTL Punkt 12 starting at 01:08:40:

AI Summary:
Life in Darkness – Living with ME/CFS


A life in darkness, silence, and isolation — this is the reality for Katharina, who suffers from ME/CFS, a severe neurological disease that can affect anyone. Together with journalist Roberta Bieling, the program aims to raise awareness of this devastating illness, which makes normal life almost impossible. Despite over half a million Germans being affected, many doctors remain uninformed. There are no medications available, and research progress is slow.




Despair and Protest


Families of those affected describe ME/CFS as a nightmare. One mother’s daughter has been bedridden for three and a half years, unable to have social contact. She and others feel abandoned by the healthcare system. Estimates suggest that soon around one million people in Germany could be suffering from ME/CFS. Patients and their families are demanding more research funding and effective treatment options. On October 15, the patient organization Mein Kind kann nicht mehr placed 200 body bags in front of the Federal Ministry of Research — a symbolic protest calling for political action.




The Story of Jonas


Jonas, once able to walk and talk, now lies bedridden. His father decorates the ceiling to bring him small moments of joy. His condition worsened after a hospital stay where doctors seemed poorly informed. Jonas and his father experienced insensitive treatment — doctors doubted the physical nature of his illness and even questioned his mental stability. These traumatic experiences have left lasting emotional scars on both father and son.




Lack of Understanding and Misdiagnosis


Many relatives call for better education among doctors. Although numerous studies have identified biological causes — involving the brain, circulatory, and nervous systems, as well as energy metabolism — patients are often treated as if they had psychological disorders. Experts explain that because the disease is invisible, poorly understood, and difficult to treat, many physicians fail to take it seriously.




Katharina’s Life in Darkness


Katharina from Aachen is now 29 years old. Once full of energy and joy, she loved traveling and sharing laughter with others. Now, she lives in darkness, cared for by her mother Ruth for the past year and a half. The family receives €900 in care benefits but spends around €2,500 per month on additional medical and nutritional needs. Her mother asks why there are no public awareness campaigns and why families must pay so much out of pocket and fight through months of bureaucracy for minimal support.




Government Silence and Limited Research Funding


Attempts to interview Health Minister Nina Wagen about the lack of support have failed. The Research Ministry, led by Dorothee Bär, refers to €64 million previously allocated for ME/CFS research — an amount experts like Professor Klaus Wirth say is far too little. He estimates that developing a medication takes 8–10 years and that new funding is urgently needed.


According to the ME/CFS Research Foundation, the annual economic loss due to Long Covid and ME/CFS is €63 billion. Former Health Minister Karl Lauterbach states that €1 billion in research funding would be necessary and that failing to provide it would be a form of government failure.




Public Reactions and Political Statements


Instead of addressing the issue directly, Minister Bär responded to a young girl’s TikTok video with sympathy but no concrete solutions. Researchers emphasize that the real problem is not time, but lack of funding. Families feel helpless as they continue to care for their loved ones with no treatment or hope in sight.




A Plea for Help


The segment ends with the voices of children and young adults expressing their wishes — to travel again, see friends, ride horses, play sports, and live without pain. Their hopes remain unanswered. Viewers are encouraged to donate to Stiftung RTL, which supports ME/CFS patients and their families. The program promises to continue covering this issue in the coming years.
 

National Decade Against Post-Infectious Diseases / Half a billion Euros for Research​


New thread: https://www.s4me.info/threads/germanys-national-decade-against-post-infectious-diseases.47159/

Original Webpage: https://www.bmftr.bund.de/SharedDocs/Kurzmeldungen/DE/2025/11/nationale-dekade-postinfektiöse-erkrankungen.html

National Decade Against Post-Infectious Diseases


News November 13, 2025


Federal Research Minister Bär: "We are opening a new chapter in the research of these diseases."

65622teg_fc50c49f58bcbc5.jpg

© BMFTR

Post-infectious diseases such as Long COVID or ME/CFS represent an immense burden for those affected and their families. Effective treatment options are still lacking. To change this, Federal Research Minister Dorothee Bär, together with partners in health research, will launch the National Decade Against Post-Infectious Diseases. The aim is to decipher causes and mechanisms and to develop new treatment options.


Half a billion euros for a new chapter of research​


The National Decade Against Post-Infectious Diseases runs from 2026 to 2036 and is to be funded with a total of 500 million euros.


Following the budget committee's reconciliation meeting on November 13, 2025, Federal Research Minister Dorothee Bär emphasized: "With the National Decade, we are opening a new chapter in research on these diseases. We need a long-term strategy to better understand the causes and mechanisms of post-infectious diseases and to sustainably improve the care of those affected."


The Minister underlined the urgency of this decade: "From many conversations, I know what a great burden these diseases represent for those affected and their families. The need for research is enormous: There are still no simple solutions or therapies for ME/CFS and post-viral autoimmune diseases, and previous scientific studies demonstrate the complexity of the disease mechanisms."


A milestone for those affected​


Worldwide, there are currently no sufficiently evidence-based therapeutic approaches for the effective and curative treatment of post-infectious diseases. Current therapies are limited to the treatment of symptoms


Understanding disease mechanisms is key: Only when the causes and biological processes of diseases are better understood can targeted new diagnostic and therapeutic methods be developed. The National Decade will now expand and anchor research in the long term – a crucial step in the fight against post-infectious diseases.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
After yesterday's positive news, here's why many pwME aren't overly optimistic because the money could be used to fund more BPS nonsense.

All three recommend GET or even inpatient rehab facilities for pwME.


AI summary:

Expert Assessments on ME/CFS Rehabilitation

1. Volker Köllner

Position

- Head of the Research Group for Psychosomatic Rehabilitation at Charité Berlin
- Medical Director of the Rehabilitation Center Seehof in Teltow

Summary of viewpoint
- Rehabilitation can benefit many ME/CFS patients, particularly those with mild to moderate disease.
- The Bell Score is a pragmatic tool to judge rehab suitability.
- ME/CFS typically presents a complex symptom profile (fatigue, post-exertional malaise (PEM), cognitive deficits, respiratory complaints, psychological comorbidities), so a multimodal rehab concept is sensible.
- Evidence referenced includes a systematic review identifying behavioral therapy + exercise therapy among the few evidence-based options, and a large German cohort (>1,000 rehabilitants) reporting ~90% satisfaction and improvements in at least one area; cognitive performance showed small to medium effect sizes.
- Chronic ME/CFS is not an absolute contraindication for rehab; goals become preventing progression, supporting coping, improving everyday competence (especially pacing), assessing individual capacity, and clarifying vocational perspectives.
- Severely ill patients who are not rehab-capable may need longer, personnel-intensive hospital care; ambulatory or partly digital programs could help but are underdeveloped in Germany.

2. Rembert Koczulla

Position

- Chief Physician, Specialized Center for Pneumology, Schön Clinic Berchtesgadener Land
- W3 Professor of Pulmonary Rehabilitation, University of Marburg

Summary of viewpoint
- Underlying pathomechanisms of ME/CFS are poorly understood; there are no reliable biomarkers and no firmly established therapeutic approaches—this limits clear rehab recommendations.
- Many Long-COVID rehabilitation trials did not differentiate or excluded ME/CFS patients, so evidence for this subgroup is weak. For people without ME/CFS, rehab shows clear benefits (QoL, physical capacity, less dyspnea/fatigue), but this cannot be simply extrapolated.
- Exercise therapy is controversial because it may worsen PEM; PEM is often not systematically recorded in studies, complicating interpretation.
- For Long-COVID patients reporting low to moderate PEM, experts currently advise a very cautious, individually adaptive activation approach. Early limited data suggest only a minority worsen, but sample sizes are small.
- Key questions: can biomarkers/phenotyping identify ME/CFS patients who would benefit from individualized activation? Should even mild PEM exclude patients from movement-based rehab? What should specialized ME/CFS rehab prioritize?
- Warning: prolonged absence of activation may cause sarcopenia and additional functional decline—so inactivity has risks.
- Calls for standardized diagnosis, standardized PEM assessment, and controlled rehabilitative trials with adaptive monitoring.

3. Peter Berlit

Position
- Prof. Dr. med. Peter Berlit, Secretary General of the German Society for Neurology

Summary of viewpoint
- For many ME/CFS patients, outpatient therapy is sufficient.
- In moderate ME/CFS with PEM, an individualized rehabilitation program is often appropriate.
- Severe PEM requires that physical and mental pacing be done only under supervision.
- Depending on individual symptoms, a combination of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and graded exercise therapy (GET) may be indicated, alongside support for perceiving and processing symptoms.
- Before selecting rehab measures, clinicians should systematically assess residual organ-specific symptoms (pulmonary, cardiovascular, CNS) after infections (e.g., SARS-CoV-2) and treat psychiatric comorbidities. The Bell Score can be used for monitoring.
- Rehab facilities should apply a biopsychosocial approach offering somatic and psychosocial treatments, cardiopulmonary-monitored training, psychotherapy, and behavioral therapy.
- Optimistic stance: “Even with chronic symptoms, improvement and recovery are possible.” He cautions that inactivity, isolation, and sensory deprivation increase risk of worsening and disability; rehab potential should be discussed and positive recovery experiences may be motivating.
 
Last edited:
After yesterday's positive news, here's why many pwME aren't overly optimistic because the money could be used to fund more BPS nonsense.

All three recommend GET or even inpatient rehab facilities for pwME.


AI summary:

“Conflict of interest: The author (i.e. Prof. Dr. med. Volker Köllner) states that he has received royalties and an author's fee from Elsevier Publishing, fees for expert opinions in court, lecture fees from Synaptikon, SRH Vocational Training Center and the University of Würzburg, as well as funds for studies from the German Pension Insurance (DRV).”

I think his stance is well expected for a scientist payed by the National Pension Insurance Agency. However that really looks utterly ugly and pessimistic. At least lets hope that the hardcore pro-ME team in Charite Berlin will achieve to secure a part of the Funds.
 
Last edited:
All three recommend GET or even inpatient rehab facilities for pwME.
How depressing, Professor Köllner argues based on this obscure paywalled case study as if it’s the newest idea ever.
Ein stationäres Therapieprogramm für schwerstbetroffene Post-COVID-Patient:innen, 2025, Haberger et al

Ein stationäres Therapieprogramm für schwerstbetroffene Post-COVID-Patient:innen

Haberger, Rita; Montanari, Ida; Schmalenberger, Daniel; Mohr, Arno; Peters, Katharina; Loew, Thomas H.

Abstract
A stationary therapy program for severely affected post-COVID patients
There is a current lack of specialized inpatient services for severely affected post-COVID patients, who often require care for years and do not respond to outpatient therapies.
The strength of psychosomatic clinics lies in the medical interdisciplinarity and customized multimodal treatment.
A therapy program at Clinic Donaustauf in cooperation with the University Hospital of Regensburg combines extended basic care, distance from the stressful environment, and fit-for-purpose physiotherapy, cognitive training, biofeedback-supported medical therapy, emotional support, and psychotherapy.
The goals are to build performance, reduce disease-related fear, and prepare for further rehabilitation and social participation.
Our treatment takes up to about four to six months.

Web | DOI | Ärztliche Psychotherapie

Our treatment takes up to about four to six months.
4-6 months in a clinic… Why not 2 years?



I’ve never come across this one before: Professor Koczulla mentions „self-reported PEM“.
Self-reported, that can‘t be good, right…? right?!



And then there’s Professor Berlit from the Deutschen Gesellschaft für Neurologie who talks about his personal intuition about the possibility of healing, the dangers of inactivity & sensory deprivation, and of course the importance of recovery stories from pwLC —without backing that up with a single worthwhile study. Sigh!

Here are the two studies highlighted by him:

Some comments from our community:
This appears to have been done by a research student supervised by Chalder. He's decribed as Mr Tom Ingman, former student. It looks like this article was completed back in October 2019, so it seems to have taken a long time to find a journal stupid enough to publish it.

I was referred to Dr Chalder in Autumn 2020 and throughout the entire 1 hour interview she never asked about my symptoms, the entire thing was attempting to find some childhood trauma that was responsible for my illness. I had wised up by this point and already knew what ME/CFS was after my GP had exercised me into severe condition. Suffice to say everything people say about this person is spot on accurate, she is dangerous to ME/CFS patients and should never receive NHS money.

Second study:
 


There were some interesting participants at this discussion:

On the Podium
  • Dr. Christian Gogoll, Specialist in Internal Medicine and Pneumology, Lead Author of the Patient Guideline on Long Covid (that's the patient's version of the official S1 Leitlinie.)
  • Max B. Eckert, Research Associate and Data Scientist at CityLAB of the Technology Foundation Berlin, Co-developer of a Post-Covid Data Model
  • Dr. Elisa Stein, Institute for Medical Immunology at Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Researches Post-Covid and ME/CFS
  • Moderation: Axel Dorloff


Defining Long COVID and Its Symptoms (01:26)


Long COVID, or Post-COVID Syndrome, is defined by the WHO as symptoms that persist or newly appear twelve weeks after a COVID-19 infection, are not attributable to other causes, and negatively impact daily life. Central to the condition is a profound fatigue, often accompanied by post-exertional malaise (PEM), where physical, mental, or emotional exertion worsens symptoms. Other common complaints include cognitive impairments like "brain fog," various forms of pain (muscle, nerve, headache), and sleep disturbances. The specific presentation of symptoms can vary significantly among patients.



The Patient's Journey and Healthcare System Hurdles (03:07)


Dr. Christian Gogol, a physician and Long COVID patient himself, shared his personal experience, which highlighted the significant challenges in accessing coordinated care. After a severe case of COVID-19 requiring ventilation, he struggled to find appropriate follow-up care, facing long waits for specialists like cardiologists and pneumologists. This experience underscored the need for a clear point of contact, like a general practitioner, to guide patients through the fragmented healthcare system. Dr. Gogol's journey led him to contribute to the development of patient guidelines for Long COVID to address this gap in care.



Data-Related Challenges in Long COVID Research (08:36)


Data scientist Max Eckert emphasized the difficulties in Long COVID research due to the fragmented and often inaccessible nature of health data. Information is collected in various "silos" across hospitals, private practices, and rehabilitation centers, often in non-standardized or even analog formats. This lack of interoperability makes it difficult to track patients over time and to compare the effectiveness of different therapies. Mr. Eckert and his team are developing a data model to integrate clinical data with other data sources, such as environmental data, to better understand the disease.



The Link Between Long COVID and ME/CFS (12:57)


A significant portion of the discussion was dedicated to the relationship between Long COVID and Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS). Dr. Elisa Stein explained that ME/CFS is a pre-existing, though poorly understood, condition characterized by severe fatigue and PEM, often triggered by an infection. A subset of Long COVID patients meets the diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS, which is considered a severe form of the post-COVID syndrome. The diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS are more stringent than for the broader category of Long COVID and require the exclusion of other medical conditions.



Diagnostic Challenges in Clinical Practice (16:53)


Diagnosing Long COVID, and particularly ME/CFS, in a general practice setting is challenging. General practitioners face the task of differentiating Long COVID from other conditions with similar symptoms, such as depression. A significant hurdle is the care for severely affected, bed-bound patients who cannot visit a doctor's office. These patients are often invisible to the healthcare system, and there is a lack of infrastructure for home-based diagnosis and care.



The Pathophysiology of Long COVID (19:53)


While the exact causes of Long COVID are still under investigation, several mechanisms are being explored. Dr. Stein outlined several key hypotheses, including:



  • Autoimmunity: The development of autoantibodies that attack the body's own tissues.
  • Viral Persistence: The continued presence of the virus or its components in the body.
  • Chronic Inflammation: A persistent inflammatory state.
  • Endothelial Dysfunction: Changes in the blood vessels.
  • Autonomic Dysfunction: Dysregulation of the autonomic nervous system.
It is likely that different subgroups of patients are affected by different primary mechanisms.

The Role of Data and Patient Trust in Research (22:21)


The panel stressed the importance of a patient-centered approach to data collection and the need for a robust digital infrastructure to advance Long COVID research. Building trust is crucial to encourage patients to share their data for research purposes. Currently, patients often have to repeat their medical history at each new appointment, a burden that could be alleviated by a unified electronic patient record.



Prevalence and Economic Burden (25:35)


The exact number of people affected by Long COVID is difficult to determine, but estimates for Germany range from 1.5 million individuals, with an estimated economic impact of 63 billion euros per year. The guideline group for Long COVID estimates that about 5% of those infected with COVID-19 develop persistent symptoms.



The Role of University Hospitals and General Practitioners (28:48)


Specialized centers, such as the fatigue center at the Charité university hospital in Berlin, initially saw a broad range of Long COVID patients. As the pandemic progressed, they have focused on patients with suspected ME/CFS for specialized diagnosis and inclusion in clinical trials. The PASCare network, a collaboration between the Charité and general practitioners, aims to improve the care of patients with post-infectious syndromes by integrating research and clinical practice.



Treatment Strategies and Off-Label Use (34:24)


Current treatment for Long COVID is primarily symptomatic. The repurposing of existing drugs, known as off-label use, is a significant challenge. While some medications, like low-dose naltrexone or antihistamines, show promise for certain symptoms, their use is not covered by public health insurance in Germany due to a lack of specific approval for Long COVID. Pharmaceutical companies have been hesitant to invest in the necessary clinical trials.



Future Perspectives and Therapeutic Hope (44:51)


The panel concluded on a cautiously optimistic note. Dr. Stein expressed hope in therapies targeting the immune system, such as monoclonal antibodies. However, she emphasized that a "one-size-fits-all" solution is unlikely and that a multimodal treatment approach tailored to the individual patient's symptoms and underlying mechanisms will be necessary. Dr. Gogol advocated for the establishment of competence centers to provide long-term, coordinated care for Long COVID patients. Mr. Eckert sees the electronic patient record and new legislation on health data usage as important steps toward a more data-driven and effective healthcare system.
 

Attachments

Die Ärztezeitung has an article on how to diagnose ME/CFS for GPs (only accessible for medical professionals with an account):

5 Criteria of Charité
ME/CFS Diagnosis: How to Proceed in General Practice


Post-exertional malaise (PEM) is a helpful key symptom that may indicate ME/CFS. With additional tests, the diagnosis can often be confirmed — although this does require a certain amount of effort.
 
Last edited:
This document about a panel decision to not recommend funding a phase 2b Inebilizumab (Uplizna) trial was obtained by an FOI request to the German Ministry of Education.

View attachment 29220

Source:
Wow, I'm surprised how critical this is. I mean, we're talking about €3 million, so it's good to make sure the trial design is sound. But is it typical to take issue with so many parts of a protocol?

I put the image into OCR to turn into text for easier reading, and added line breaks:
Summary of the Panel Discussion: There are major concerns regarding a clear commercial interest by AMGEN holding the patent for the thal drug - even in the case of a preliminary small phase II trial. The response to the previous reviewers' comments is not convincing in this regard.

Another limitation is the dramatically decreasing number of new COVID cases leading to ME. Therefore, no clear unmet need for the small hyper-selected plasmapheresis-responded population is seen. Also, recruitment of this population is judged to be challenging.

Concerning study design, existing evidence does not rationalize using the SF-36 scale as primary end point. Additionally, the estimated high treatment effect seems unrealistic.

Moreover, the duration of the treatment is not sufficiently justified. Furthermore, a potential placebo effect cannot be ruled out with such a short time of treatment.

Combining COVID and non-COVID conditions is seen as not optimal (see also statistical concerns). It is appreciated that applicants plan a sex-stratified randomization procedure to guard against bias. Given the robust evidence base for sex/gender differences in autoimmune conditions (including in ME/CFS) and the lack of sex sensitive analyses in the cited and pertinent studies, sex-stratified analyses should be considered - despite the small sample size.

The patient involvement is very good in general. However, a weakness is the financial renumeration which is seen as much too low, especially given the high work load.

Additionally, there are several major concerns regarding the biostatistical planning, e.g.: Randomisation is planned to be stratified for sex and type of infection that caused ME/CFS (COVID versus non-COVID). While the factors might in principle be relevant, the use of four strata is not supported with such a small sample size. It is questioned that meaningful results could be obtained.

Regarding the planned methods for the analysis of the primary endpoint, measures for study success should have been defined. The basis of the planned significance testing is not sufficiently solid.

It is also unclear why the proposed statistical analysis method is used. While indeed there might be heteroscedasticity, it is unclear in how far this impacts the study results in an RCT. It is also not clear from the cited literature if the method is suitable for a repeated measures situation. It is also not clear if the "factorial design" aspect which is the basis of the proposal is of relevance here.

Missing values will be discussed individually. While this is in principle acceptable for an exploratory study, more weight should be put on the avoidance of missing values (at least in key parameters) and strategies for intercurrent events should be pre-specified as outlined in the ICH E9 (R1) addendum on estimands. This is especially important given the very small sample size.

Panel Decision: Due to the above-mentioned shortcomings the proposed trial is not recommended for funding.
 
Die Frankfurter Rundschau has a 1000 word piece about a family wherein two kids are very sick post-vac sufferers:

The son is also severely ill and confined to the house. A rheumatology medication helped briefly but led to a liver inflammation — a side effect of the drug.

Four Years of Suffering After the Covid Vaccination

Family Situation and Daily Struggles

Nadine Schneider’s 14-year-old daughter has again been unable to attend school since March, suffering from severe nerve, joint, muscle, head, and abdominal pain. Painkillers offer no relief, and her circulation is so weak that even sitting is difficult. She also experiences sleep disturbances and profound exhaustion; on some days she must be carried to the bathroom. Both she and her brother have been fighting Post-Vaccine Syndrome and Long Covid for four years, likely triggered by a Covid-19 vaccination in 2021.
The son is also severely ill and housebound. A rheumatology drug helped briefly but caused liver inflammation. Instead of celebrating adulthood, he undergoes hyperbaric oxygen therapy. Social life, hobbies, and sports have largely disappeared due to the risk of overexertion and infections.

Lack of Support in Healthcare and Society
Although some progress has been made, Schneider still reports major obstacles in healthcare, schools, insurers, and authorities. Many doctors remain insufficiently informed. Germany counts hundreds of thousands of Long Covid patients, many developing ME/CFS, which is difficult to diagnose and affects numerous children and adolescents. Families often face similar challenges, with one parent frequently giving up work to provide care. Schneider emphasizes the lack of perspectives: therapies, research, and centralized data collection are urgently needed.

New Networks and Insufficient Medical Access
The new Pednet-LC network focuses on research and care for children with Long Covid, post-infectious, and post-vaccine syndromes, including 20 pediatric clinics established since March. Many are overwhelmed or still being set up. In Hesse, the only clinic in Kassel canceled the daughter’s long-awaited four-day inpatient stay, offering only a one-hour video appointment. The now-adult son was rejected by both pediatric and adult clinics due to full waiting lists. Frankfurt’s Post-Covid clinic has stopped accepting new patients.

Financial Burdens and Uncertain Treatments
Over four years, Schneider has visited more than 50 clinics and practices. While psychological explanations are no longer suggested, effective treatments remain unclear. The family pays nearly everything themselves—about 2,000 euros per month—depleting the parents’ retirement savings. The children take up to 40 capsules daily, ranging from supplements to blood thinners, but these only ease symptoms. Blood washing helps but is extremely expensive. Treatments are tested at the family’s own risk.

School Barriers and Administrative Hurdles
The son hopes to complete 12th grade, but the school refuses due to excessive absences. The daughter receives only five hours of online lessons. An application for a classroom avatar is stalled because all teachers and parents must sign data-protection agreements—often a barrier to children’s right to education. Schneider calls for better awareness and support from schools and education authorities.

Hopes for Research and Better Policies
Schneider had hoped for progress through the former health minister’s 120-million-euro Long Covid initiative. But projects like Pednet-LC are funded for only four years, with no long-term plan. She urges policymakers to invest more in research and prevention now, as more children and adults fall ill and each new infection increases risk. Despite setbacks, she continues to hope that research will eventually give her children a normal life.
 
Back
Top Bottom