New Zealand: 2022 Petition for the NZ government to recognise ME/CFS as a disability - deadline 29 August 2022 (people living outside NZ can sign)

Maybe someone could contact the author about the continuous use of 'chronic fatigue' in such articles that only add to the problem of proper recognition.
Have written to request a change of headline and also suggested a few options for replacing the link to the NIH with a NZ source.
I’m grateful to anyone who puts themselves forward for a media interview. But in the video clip, the wording seemed to give the impression the extra expenses were holistic health therapies like massage and acupuncture, which some might consider non-essential.
Yes. I considered mentioning the video in my email but chickened out. Didn't feel comfortable criticising another patient. But you're right, the video is misleading. Whether that's more due to editing or more due to the patient not having enough awareness of how the things we say can get (mis)interpreted by viewers is hard to say. It should be the job of journalists to ensure sensitive coverage of stigmatised illnesses rather than the job of every patient brave enough to step forward to have to undergo media training first.
 
Signed. Very easy. Takes about 2 seconds to do.
Yes, it is very easy. And the petition is very straightforward in its request.

Up to 2758.

This is all of the text that is part of the petition.
Petition request
That the House of Representatives urge the Government to reclassify Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) from chronic illness to disability.

Petition reason
People with this condition face barriers to support under the chronic illness classification, and we believe this results in poor quality of life and health inequity. We believe that reclassification will lead to real improvements for those in need, providing access to much needed home help, housing support, financial support, and counselling. Following COVID-19 infection, many people are reported to receive a ME/CFS diagnosis and also require ongoing support services.

Does anyone have a link to a list of health conditions that are classified as a disability in New Zealand, and specifically what benefits reclassification might bring?


Yes. I considered mentioning the video in my email but chickened out. Didn't feel comfortable criticising another patient. But you're right, the video is misleading. Whether that's more due to editing or more due to the patient not having enough awareness of how the things we say can get (mis)interpreted by viewers is hard to say. It should be the job of journalists to ensure sensitive coverage of stigmatised illnesses rather than the job of every patient brave enough to step forward to have to undergo media training first.
I agree that that segment of the message was a problem in what was otherwise a good video clip. I think ANZMES and other patient organisations have a role to play in preventing statements like that. Sick people desperate to be well and with no medical background should not have to do the heavy lifting when it comes to trying to work out whether acupuncture or yoga or massage are going to be useful treatments.

ANZMES currently provides a link to Dr Ros Vallings' guide on management of CFS
The best form of management of ME/CFS is outlined by Dr. Vallings here: http://www.drvallings.co.nz/management.html
https://anzmes.org.nz/what-is-me/frequently-asked-questions/
Dr Vallings' advice includes acupuncture, and massage and yoga:
A positive attitude is the first step in the right direction together with avoidance of stress as far as possible.

Many have found that a combination of rest, gentle exercise and stress management has put them back on their feet.

A simple exercise plan should be adhered to with a very gradual build up in fitness. A sensible plan should include some movement, however minimal, of each joint and muscle each day. As your health improves a short walk could be included in the day's activities. Initially a few paces could be undertaken, increasing by say 5 paces a day until you are able to walk to the local dairy or beach. Remember you need enough energy in reserve to return home. If symptoms worsen at any time, the exercise programme will need to be adjusted. It is a good idea to chart progress as this is one way of measuring recovery over a period of time, which can be very encouraging.

Many people with CFS tend to breathe poorly which maybe due to sluggish or tired repiratory muscles, or extreme anxiety.

Vitamin B12 has been shown to be useful in some overseas studies and needs to be administered by injection to ensure efficient absorption.

CoEnzyme Q10 (50-200mg) can also help with myalgia.

Some people have been helped by the use of a TENS machine, which works by passing a gentle electrical current along sensitised nerve fibres. A physiotherapist can advise about obtaining and using one of these devices. Acupuncture is occasionally helpful, but it is important that your practitioner has complete understanding of the illness.

The use of the newer SSRI and SRNI antidepressants has been shown to be useful in lifting mood in CFS people.

I got bored copying lines, but that advice is chock full of patronising statements that are unsupported or disproved by evidence.

If ANZMES' medical advisor is saying this rubbish, how can we expect people with ME/CFS to know better? ANZMES seriously needs to get its house in order. There's other bad stuff on the website, for example, to support a statement that ME/CFS is not psychosomatic, they give a link to a video on the metabolic trap theory. ANZMES is multiplying the misinformation out there rather than correcting it.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone have a link to a lost of health conditions that are classified as a disability in New Zealand, and specifically what benefits reclassification might bring?
Haven't been able to find anything conclusive but the fact that these organisations are listed on this page would suggest these conditions are classed as 'disabilities'. MS is on the list so that would make a good argument that ME should be, too.
https://whaikaha.govt.nz/assessment...ind-disability-information-advisory-services/
As for the benefits of a reclassification, the ANZMES page explains it a bit better than the petition text.
ANZMES: https://anzmes.org.nz/petition-disability/

I know of people who have one family member with ME and another with a recognised disability and they report that they get more support for the latter even if the pwME has higher needs.

In the long term there's a push for ACC to be reformed to cover all impairment irrespective of cause but this could take decades to implement if it ever happens.
 
As for the benefits of a reclassification, the ANZMES page explains it a bit better than the petition text.
ANZMES: https://anzmes.org.nz/petition-disability/
It's a bit better, but it still doesn't link to a government page that lists specific health conditions that automatically get better treatment. I think the petition is worth signing, but someone must have that information in order to feel that a petition is worthwhile. I think ANZMES, as the petition organiser, should be specific about where they want ME/CFS to be listed.

From that ANZMES page that Ravn linked:
Who are ANZMES?
ANZMES has been providing information, building awareness, funding research, and advocating for people with ME/CFS for the past 42 years (since 1980). As the national advisory body for ME/CFS in New Zealand, ANZMES disseminates evidence-based information nationally, and represents the ME/CFS voice globally as a founding member of the World ME Alliance. ANZMES acts as the voice of all people living with this disabling disease through advocacy and leadership.
No, they are currently disseminating information that is not evidence-based. With them endorsing the use of acupuncture and advice that essentially amounts to GET, they are not acting as my voice.
 
Are they suggesting ME should be specifically included on this disability certificate https://www.workandincome.govt.nz/documents/forms/disability-certificate.pdf
I'd be surprised, as it lists all sorts of disabilities including "stress". Also, ANZMES said that the reclassification would enable people with ME/CFS to access help with housing costs and home help. The Disability Allowance doesn't cover that, it's mostly related to the costs of going to the doctor and prescriptions. Maybe there is another list that suggests that certain disabilities should be regarded as permanent. I've tried googling a bit, but didn't find anything.

If ANZMES was very specific about what they wanted, it would increase the chances of things changing in the right direction.
 
Kiwis with chronic fatigue 'extremely disappointed' officials won't reclassify illness

Kiwis living with the “debilitating” impacts of myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) say it is “extremely disappointing” officials do not plan to recognise the condition as a disability.

This month, the Associated New Zealand ME Society submitted a petition to Parliament calling for ME/CFS to be reclassified from a chronic illness to a disability, to better help people access support. It closed on Monday, after garnering 6400 signatures.

The Ministry of Health said it understood the impact of illnesses such as ME or CFS “can be significant for individuals and their whānau, and that the symptoms can be experienced as disabling”.

Despite this, the ministry said it was “not currently looking into reclassification for ME/CFS”.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/he...isappointed-officials-wont-reclassify-illness
 
Back
Top Bottom