Ask Dr Ellie Cannon recommends GET - Mail on Sunday

Gecko

Senior Member (Voting Rights)
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-6197085/ASK-DR-ELLIE-CANNON-clear-big-lump-throat.html

I have recently been diagnosed with ME. How long must I put up with this fatigue?

ME, now more commonly known as chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), may arise after a period of physical or mental health problems, or even without prior warning.

Putting a timeframe on the condition is difficult but one study suggests about 40 per cent of sufferers improve after five years.

Treatment can be beneficial but will not offer a cure.

Many experts now think CFS stems from problems with the nervous system. It is not uncommon for people to suffer fatigue after a virus or illness. But no conclusive link has ever been found.

The most important thing is to get a GP referral to the nearest CFS clinic. Sleep, rest and relaxation techniques are also incredibly important.

Graded exercise therapy is the mainstay of CFS treatment.

This involves a programme of activity tailored to suit an individual and should ideally be under the supervision of a physiotherapist or occupational therapist.

In trials, cognitive behavioural therapy has been shown to be effective. It’s also important to note that before CFS is diagnosed, tests must be carried out to rule out the other common causes of fatigue.

I assume this is just mindless regurgitation with zero research.
 
About the author - google blurb on her book:

Dr Ellie Cannon is a GP with a particular interest in family health. With over a decade of experience, Dr Ellie has helped thousands of families adjust to life with a new baby and understands deep down what really matters to parents. She is the go-to health expert for Sky News, Channel 5 and Daybreak and this autumn will be starring in a new Channel 4 health series. Dr Ellie is also the resident GP for the Mail on Sunday, Woman magazineand Mailonline. She is the mother of two young children.

Jack of all trades.....
 
ME, now more commonly known as chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), may arise after a period of physical or mental health problems, or even without prior warning.

So it could arise after the only three possible possibilities and also because at first a doc might just tell you you are mentally ill even though it was actually ME, the dustbin diagnosis you started of with has to still stand in your medical notes.

You may get cancer after a physical illness or a mental illness or not or you may get it without any of those things happening first.



Putting a timeframe on the condition is difficult but one study suggests about 40 per cent of sufferers improve after five years.

"One study!! " :banghead:


Treatment can be beneficial but will not offer a cure.

Great!! This is encouraging! More beneficial than Lucozade and grapes or less beneficial or nearly the same?

Many experts now think CFS stems from problems with the nervous system. It is not uncommon for people to suffer fatigue after a virus or illness.

Hanging on your every word. Whats fatigue got to do with anything though.

The most important thing is to get a GP referral to the nearest CFS clinic.

Let me guess, so one can hear more of this shit?

Sleep, rest and relaxation techniques are also incredibly important.

Wow tell us more.

Graded exercise therapy is the mainstay of CFS treatment.

2018 and she is still spouting this crap??

This involves a programme of activity tailored to suit an individual and should ideally be under the supervision of a physiotherapist or occupational therapist.

So wait that's pacing not GET? If it is pacing why would it be called a treatment?

In trials, cognitive behavioural therapy has been shown to be effective.

Wrong!

It’s also important to note that before CFS is diagnosed, tests must must be carried out to rule out the other common causes of fatigue.

Not according to the "experts" she got the above drivel from. Tests are actively discouraged according to them.
 
Last edited:
Not according to the "experts" she got the above drivel from. Tests are actively discouraged according to them.

I think tests are only discouraged after disgnosis. Initial tests to rule out other possibilities are recommended. But if those tests don’t pick the problem up, it seems they should be regarded as definitive*, and further explorations are discouraged and CBT/GET is the next step.

* IE They say “We could find nothing wrong with this patient” - which WE know does not mean the same as ‘there IS nothing wrong’, but that is the way it is interpreted, and after this point the medic is discouraged from testing further. Sometimes, when new symptoms appear these are ignored also.
 
Last edited:


MEA: Mail on Sunday: Ask Dr Ellie Cannon – Recently diagnosed with M.E. How long must I put up with this fatigue? | 24 September 2018

https://www.meassociation.org.uk/20...ecently-diagnosed-with-m-e-24-september-2018/

In yesterday’s Daily Mail, in the regular “Ask Dr Ellie Cannon” column, a question was featured about M.E.

Dr Charles Shepherd has responded with the following information to Dr Cannon, hoping this might provide her with more accurate information and a better understanding of the disease...
 
Thes
True, but nobody's perfect. ;)
I'd also like to know the evidence for it being a minority who get worse over time.

These quotes are from the CMO 2002 report. So quite a while ago and before forums and FB groups were as popular.

I think it's a generally good response, especially as a fair amount of his w/e was spent responding re the "Sussex" post.
 
Back
Top Bottom