[2] South Africa: rapid point of service breath tests, trials pending
Date: Mon 15 Jun 2020
Source: The Scientist [edited]
<
https://tinyurl.com/y9ajsnkj>
In Hillbrow, a suburb of Johannesburg, South Africa, researchers are
gearing up to start a trial to assess a rapid breath test for COVID-19
to deliver results on-site in less than 5 minutes. If successful, the
test would offer the advantages of being non-invasive, easy to use,
and appropriate in settings other than hospitals.
"We believe that breath is potentially a powerful medium in detecting
certain diseases early," says Mohammed Majam, the head of medical
technologies at Ezintsha, an academic policy and research unit of the
health sciences faculty at the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits).
"We are evaluating if this is the same for a virus like [SARS-CoV-2].
Our body responds immediately to the virus metabolically, and in the
process, unique gases are produced. These gases are a signature of the
virus and a breath test would be able to capture that," Majam, who
previously worked on the evaluation of HIV self-tests for the World
Health Organization in South Africa, tells The Scientist.
The investigators are waiting on approval from regulatory authorities
to begin the test and work out the logistics of importing it into
South Africa, as many tests suppliers have been affected by lockdown
regulations. If all moves ahead, the scientists will use a sensitive,
handheld device fitted with disposable nanosensors that pick up gases
in a normal exhaled breath. For the phase 1 study, breath samples will
be collected from 60 adults with positively confirmed COVID-19 and 90
negative controls. Ezintsha is assessing the product and the
developer, US-based Canary Health Technologies, would commercialize
it.
A cloud-based pattern-recognition technology will determine if a
COVID-19 breath pattern can be established with accuracy. "This study
at Wits will confirm the expected metabolic fingerprint of COVID-19
disease in the breath based on our assessment of the impact of
COVID-19 on human body," Raj Reddy, the chief executive officer of
Canary and inventor of the technology, tells The Scientist.
SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, can initiate oxidative
stress by a similar mechanism observed in other viral pneumonias,
according to Reddy, with the production of highly reactive nitrogen
oxide species. "This would in turn enhance the concentration of
alkanes and oxygenated compounds that are exhaled from the breath. A
larger load of distinctive biomarker molecules would eventually result
in higher sensor response for patients with COVID-19 disease as
compared to COVID-19 negative individuals," says Reddy. "Our
differentially reactive sensor system is expected to generate a
distinct pattern that can discriminate between people with COVID-19
disease and those without."
Scientists will then use the breath patterns to measure the
sensitivity and specificity of the test when compared to a standard
PCR-based diagnostic. Majam says he believes the test is very safe, as
the disposable sensor prevents COVID-19 infected breath from touching
the inside of the main device that is used to transmit the data to the
cloud for analysis. The machine is disinfected between uses. "Any
rapid test that could be used to identify infected individuals during
this pandemic, especially those who are asymptomatic, is very
important, says Burtram Fielding, a molecular biologist at the
University of Western Cape who has been working on coronaviruses since
2003.
Diagnostic tests modeled around the same type of technology for asthma
and lung disease are globally in use. The typical problems with these
types of tests are that they are not very specific or sensitive,
Fielding says. "This means that it could register false positives --
someone tests positive, but is not infected -- and false
negatives--someone tests negative, but is indeed infected," Fielding
tells The Scientist. The latter, he says, is of much greater concern
as an infected person could spread the disease not knowing that they
are positive. False positives could also be due to the test detecting
the same biomarkers for other, less-dangerous coronaviruses or other
types of viruses altogether.
As with all other rapid tests, this could make a good screening tool
if the sensitivity and specificity are high enough, Fielding says.
Used as a screening test, individuals testing positive could at least
be isolated while they are tested by the confirmatory RT-PCR test,
which is the gold standard. "Unless the clinical trial shows very high
sensitivity and specificity, this would not be a very useful test
during the epidemic of a virus with such a high infective rate," he
says.
In May [2020], researchers at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in
Israel announced they had developed a COVID-19 electro-optical test of
nose, throat, or breath samples that looks for signs of the virus's
presence itself and gives results in less than one minute. This
product would cost approximately USD 50. Current PCR tests range
between USD 45 and USD 70. "We believe we will be able to produce the
tests at a significantly lower cost," says Majam.
Canary Health is discussing plans to conduct clinical trials on the
device in the United Kingdom and the US, but a trial planned in Hong
Kong won't go ahead now that there are very few COVID-19 cases,
according to Anna Wang, Canary's senior vice president for corporate
affairs.
"We will seek accelerated regulatory approval in South Africa as soon
as they are confident of the performance, [and we hope] to have this
test on the market before the end of 2020," Wang says.
[byline: Munyaradzi Makoni]
--
communicated by:
ProMED-mail
<
promed@promedmail.org>
[We usually do not post pre-phase 1 trials as many a good idea doesn't
pass through phase 1 to phase 2, or from phase 2 to phase 3. But this
struck me as a fascinating approach should it prove to be successful
after a rigorous case control study protocol. As mentioned above and
in prior posts, the need for point of care rapid testing is in great
demand, especially in Africa where border crossings are points where
passage of trucks carrying needed supplies and products are often
delayed at the crossing for days or even 1-2 weeks awaiting PCR test
results. In addition, international and domestic travel might benefit
greatly by a rapid point of care test.
A picture of the device is available at the source URL above. -
Mod.MPP
HealthMap/ProMED map of South Africa:
<
http://healthmap.org/promed/p/179>]