News from Aotearoa/New Zealand and the Pacific Islands

In the first of a three-part series, new data reveals the burden of Long Covid sufferers in New Zealand, from common symptoms to job losses to reduced quality of life

Newsroom spoke to them as part of a new series on Long Covid. This article details the findings of that report. Tomorrow’s will share the testimonies of the four in greater detail. And a third article will ask, where to from here?
LINK
 
part 2
https://newsroom.co.nz/2024/10/09/the-burden-kiwis-with-long-covid-speak-out/

part 3
https://newsroom.co.nz/2024/10/10/the-burden-govts-head-in-the-sand-on-cascading-long-covid/
The Burden - a Newsroom Series

Most of the country has done its best to move on from the pandemic. But there's one group who can't – those suffering the often-debilitating effects of Long Covid. Marc Daalder takes a deep dive into what life is like for these people, and what we as a country should be doing to address it.

* Part one: 'Long Covid sufferers' quality of life close to MS patients'.

Newsroom examines the results of a report into NZ's largest Long Covid research project.

* Part two: 'Kiwis with Long Covid speak out'

Four New Zealanders share their experiences of the condition in detail.

* Part three: 'Govt's head in the sand on cascading Long Covid'

Newsroom asks, what now?
 
https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/350...thers-condition-saw-her-daughter-starve-death
This is an article about a young woman who starved to death after developing gastroparesis. It seems that this was triggered by having her appendix removed.

I’ve lost track. How many teen, twenty, thirty, year old women with eating difficulties and or EDS, do doctors in this land want to neglect to death?

One doesn’t have to believe exactly everything a patient tells one about themselves and their body in order to do your best not to kill them.

But making up one’s mind that all your young hungry female patients are attempting to wipe themselves out is going to speed them on their way into an early grave. I can’t help but suspect that the ED treatment isn’t going to be all that great either. Not with this attitude towards patients.



Also the palliative psychologist, when Ruby was reaching the end stages of starving to death, telling her to gain a couple of kilograms, like she wouldn’t have thought of that. After three years begging for doctors to help her eat. If one is supposed to be offering one’s presence with a dying person, so that they may not have to go through the painful process alone, you absolutely have a duty to believe every word they utter about themselves and their condition.

‘Umm I know you’re starving, I don’t know why you don’t just eat!?’

Gaslight right into your early grave.

RIP Ruby.
 
Last edited:
I’ve lost track. How many teen, twenty, thirty, year old women with eating difficulties and or EDS, do doctors in this land want to neglect to death.

One doesn’t have to believe exactly everything a patient tells one about themselves and their body in order to do your best not to kill them.

But making up one’s mind that all your young hungry female patients are attempting to wipe themselves out is going to speed them on their way into an early grave. I can’t help but suspect that the m ED treatment isn’t going be all that great either. Not with this attitude towards patients.



Also the palliative psychologist, when Ruby was reaching the end stages of starving to death, telling her to gain a couple of kilograms, like she wouldn’t have thought of that. After three years begging for doctors to help her eat. If one is supposed to be offering one’s presence with a dying person, so that they may not have to go through the painful process alone, you absolutely have a duty to believe every word they utter about themselves and their condition.

‘Umm I know you’re starving, I don’t know why you don’t just eat!?’

Gaslight right into your early grave.

RIP Ruby.

It looks like this is an international issue. We are seeing it regularly in the UK, perhaps better reported now because it has come to be seen as newsworthy. Missing Millions France have reported there are regularly cases there where young primarily women with very severe ME are refused alternative feeding leading to malnutrition and dehydration and worse. My memory is not brilliant but haven’t there been a couple of cases in Scandinavia over the last few years?

Is that we don’t hear of it in more countries because it is not being recognised and reported? How many deaths are wrongly hidden/lost under an assumption of anorexia?

Presumably once malnutrition and dehydration have set in, unless the patient is carefully listened to, differential diagnosis becomes difficult as which presenting symptoms relate to any underlying condition and which to nutritional status.

From a very brief web search for example in the USA there are over 10,000 deaths a year attributed to anorexia nervosa (Deloitte Access Economics. The Social and Economic Cost of Eating Disorders in the United States of America: A Report for the Strategic Training Initiative for the Prevention of Eating Disorders and the Academy for Eating Disorders.June 2020. Available at: https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/striped/report-economic-costs-of-eating-disorders/). Given how fraught the situation relating to such deaths and the management of anorexia can be anyway, it is conceivable that other missed conditions particularly in young women just get subsumed.

As we have seen here in the UK not even highly motivated and formed media savvy families are enough to force appropriate alternative feeding being investigated and possibly/probably preventing death.
 
It looks like this is an international issue. We are seeing it regularly in the UK, perhaps better reported now because it has come to be seen as newsworthy. Missing Millions France have reported there are regularly cases there where young primarily women with very severe ME are refused alternative feeding leading to malnutrition and dehydration and worse. My memory is not brilliant but haven’t there been a couple of cases in Scandinavia over the last few years?

Is that we don’t hear of it in more countries because it is not being recognised and reported? How many deaths are wrongly hidden/lost under an assumption of anorexia?

Presumably once malnutrition and dehydration have set in, unless the patient is carefully listened to, differential diagnosis becomes difficult as which presenting symptoms relate to any underlying condition and which to nutritional status.

From a very brief web search for example in the USA there are over 10,000 deaths a year attributed to anorexia nervosa (Deloitte Access Economics. The Social and Economic Cost of Eating Disorders in the United States of America: A Report for the Strategic Training Initiative for the Prevention of Eating Disorders and the Academy for Eating Disorders.June 2020. Available at: https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/striped/report-economic-costs-of-eating-disorders/). Given how fraught the situation relating to such deaths and the management of anorexia can be anyway, it is conceivable that other missed conditions particularly in young women just get subsumed.

As we have seen here in the UK not even highly motivated and formed media savvy families are enough to force appropriate alternative feeding being investigated and possibly/probably preventing death.

Yes you’re correct of course.

I feel that authorities of ANZ have less excuse to keep doing this since the population
is smaller than many places and there are fewer doctors to choose from for patients and that these doctors ought to know about it when they kill their patients, considering that no one’s that far away from each other there.

But I guess that’s cancelled out by the fact that, as internationally, if you designate certain patients medically without need of treatment or else un-save-able, then you’ve made their deaths not your responsibility no matter how many of them die.
 
Last edited:
One doesn’t have to believe exactly everything a patient tells one about themselves and their body in order to do your best not to kill them.
Exactly. The idea that the patient has to be forced into some kind of bizarre 'confession' about their 'mental health issues' before qualifying for real support and treatment, and not even getting it then, is so barbaric I don't have the words for it.

It is a particularly disturbing and cruel form of social tyranny.
 
Exactly. The idea that the patient has to be forced into some kind of bizarre 'confession' about their 'mental health issues' before qualifying for real support and treatment, and not even getting it then, is so barbaric I don't have the words for it.

It is a particularly disturbing and cruel form of social tyranny.
It’s like innocent prisoners can’t go for parole if the don’t admit doing the crime and take responsibility for it

but you can’t appeal if you do
 
The Spinoff: The impact of long Covid will be huge. So why is New Zealand doing nothing about it?
Rohan Botica (Te Ātihaunui-a-Pāpārangi, Ngāti Tūwharetoa) is a lived-experience researcher and co-founder of DysImmune Research Aotearoa.

So, barring some philanthropic miracle, only government can fill this gap. Yet where Australia had set aside A$50m specifically for long Covid research, and the US Senate considers a billion-dollar long Covid “moonshot” bill, New Zealand has allocated nothing. We’re fast asleep at the wheel. No other country can determine how many of our people are impacted by post-viral illnesses. No other country can address our specific needs.

Since this government is focused on ambition, productivity and fast-tracking, I assume they’d want to be world leaders in research, warp-speed some projects, and get long Covid sufferers back into work, no? This is what we are calling for. Not surveys. Not “talk” therapy and positive thinking. Biomedical research.

Put the money down and commit to this. Seize this opportunity to right decades of neglect. There are tens of thousands of us fighting for our lives, and millions more around the world. You think it won’t be you, then after your next inevitable Covid-19 reinfection, it is, and you’re left to wonder why nobody stepped up.

Government, iwi and whānau ora groups, health organisations, philanthropists – reach out. Let’s work.
 
Contrast the above with this Newsroom piece today (currently paywalled). The first sentence reads
Newsroom said:
A single Ministry of Health staffer working four hours a week comprises the entirety of the health system's work on Long Covid, which has debilitated hundreds of New Zealanders.
Don't know where the "hundreds" comes from, presumably an error, but that sentence says all you need to know about how seriously the NZ government takes Long Covid
 
Medical Assistance in Dying

After 6 deaths, 6 years ago, on November 17, two days ago, the New Zealand Herald featured an article reporting on an inquest into these deaths. The original with photos of the 6 children is linked. The text is below the link. The action in this post happens right at the bottom of the NZH article and beyond.
LINK
 
Haven't watched yet

Webinar for health professionals for continuing medical education credits
video description said:
NAVIGATING THE COMPLEXITIES OF ME/CFS AND LONG COVID

Fiona Charlton, President, ANZMES & Dr Cathy Stephenson

Dr Cathy Stephenson,FRNZCGP, DCH, DipObs

ME/CFS and long COVID significantly impact the lives of those living with these chronic conditions. With an estimated 25-45k cases of ME/CFS in Aotearoa and growing numbers of long COVID, primary care practitioners need to feel equipped to assess patients, understand their diverse symptoms, and provide effective support. Join us for an evidence-based, practical webinar that will guide you and your patients through this challenging journey.
https://myhealthhub.co.nz/navigating-the-complexities-of-me-cfs-and-long-covid-2/
 
Radio National - Saturday morning
Last Saturday, there was an interview of Dr Toby Hillman (of the UK)
https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/saturday/audio/2018965460/dr-toby-hillman-long-covid

Tomorrow, there will be an interview two NZ Long Covid researchers:
10:05 "Kicked to the curb Kiwis": Is NZ the worst country to have Long Covid?
This week the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Covid-19 response made 39 recommendations, including that 'normal' life be kept going as much as possible during the next (inevitable) pandemic. Not music to the ears of many people living with Long Covid.

Last week, a text in response to British long covid specialist Dr Toby Hillmanclaimed "Kiwis have been kicked to the curb. NZ is one of the worst countries to have this issue with".

Rohan Botica and Dr Anna Brooks are two of the founders of DysImmune Research Aotearoa focusing on immune dysfunction research to help understand, diagnose, treat post-acute infection syndromes.

Dr Anna Brooks is a Senior Research Fellow at the Liggins Institute at the University of Auckland and Principal Investigator for DysImmune Research Aotearoa.

Rohan Botica is a Casual Research Associate at the Liggins Institute and lived-experience researcher for DysImmune.
 
Thanks for posting @Hutan. I hadn't noted the Toby Hillman interview from last week, but I thought it was very good. As commented by the interviewer, one might have imagined the general audience would want to move on from Covid/LC but no, ongoing significant interest and engagement.

I do also note that Australia (or at least Victoria) is going into a summer Covid wave now and I can't imagine NZ will avoid it. Painful to know that more people will be joining our ranks some of whom may end up severely affected.

ABC News: COVID-19 wave hits Victoria with cases and hospitalisations on rise ahead of festive season
 
Disability Support Services Operational Policy

https://fyi.org.nz/request/28659/response/113273/attach/3/OIA3500 Documents.pdf

This came up in a Google Scholar search.
Despite the first page, it looks like it was created in the last year or 2 and is mainly about ME/CFS.
I'm guessing it became available under a freedom of information request given the URL.
I‘ll leave it to others to see if it is of any interest to people in New Zealand.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom