ME/CFS Skeptic
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
Well, I agree with that. Everyone has an important responsibility for what he writes publicly and should consider the impact on others. But what you seem to imply is something much stronger: that a person has the full responsibility for everything that he says or writes publicly, as if it were direct medical advice. As I understand it that would make places like MEpedia, Wikipedia and S4ME practically impossible.Exactly. I think it is about time the general public woke up to this responsibility. We think Phil Parker has this responsibility, as an unqualified member of the general public. Everyone has this responsibility. 'First, do no harm' surely applies to everyone.
I always do my best to consider what I write on S4ME and to post things in a responsible matter. But due to my illness, I do not have a medical education and I suffer from cognitive symptoms that make me prone to errors and mistakes. If it is correct for people to interpret my blog posts here as medical advice and I bear the full responsibility for that, then the only responsible thing for me to do would be to withdraw and to stop discussing medical issues on fora such as S4ME.
I do not agree with this. Readers should comprehend that this forum is about ME/CFS patients, carers and others trying to understand the science and issues surrounding ME/CFS and helping each other with this. S4ME posts can contain errors because it is about trying to understand things and helping each other with that. Posts are not formal statements or medical advice and anyone interpreting it as such bears some responsibility in misinterpreting this. That is how I see it. Something similar is true for MEpedia - it's about the ME/CFS community trying to gather reliable and accessible information about issues that concerns them.
Is this really an issue or did we simply misinterpret each other's words?
Are there people who think MEpedia should stop because information about medical conditions and treatments should only be collected by persons who had medical training and are qualified to do so?