I couldn't think of a better title.
Of course there must be some a genetic vulnerabilities - hopefully DecodeME will find something. And of course the onset of ME/CFS seems to have something to do with infections of various pathogens.
But, all of us will have had multiple infections before the one that precipitated ME/CFS. For some of us, some of those infections will have been of the sort that are implicated in ME/CFS. So, what was it about the particular infection or the particular circumstances at the time that seems to have resulted in ME/CFS.
Or is it just random?
For example, some people are getting Long Covid on their third infection with SARS-CoV-2. Same genetics, same pathogen, different outcome. My daughter got ME/CFS after a viral infection, then recovered, and now she's had 3 Covid-19 rounds, and thankfully no return of symptoms.
Another example, I had ME/CFS for a year when I was ten, and recovered. When I was 17, I got shingles and EBV together - but I recovered quickly and easily, no ME/CFS. And then I got ME/CFS again after a viral infection when I was 47.
So, it's not just a simple equation of 'If genetics are vulnerable, and if there is an infection that causes ME/CFS, then ME/CFS'.
What other things do you think might be causing ME/CFS? What is the evidence for and against them? In my family, three of us got ME/CFS at the same time, so I have a bit of personal experience to triangulate against. I'm interested to hear your thoughts.
Over-exertion before/during the acute illness? Maybe, although I don't think that is a common factor.
Emotional stress? Again, maybe, although probably working via something like sleeplessness or smoking rate. But, I don't think it's a common factor, it wasn't for my children and I.
Hot weather or some other environmental factor like mould? I think we'd expect to see epidemics of ME/CFS, or geographic concentrations, and I don't think we have evidence of that. That said, has anyone been looking for that evidence? My children and I were in a brick house without AC for an extended heat wave, with a house full of newly delivered personal effects that had just been delivered after sitting in a container going mouldy in a tropical country, just before we got ME/CFS, so I could perhaps be persuaded about those factors.
Air pollutants e.g. sulphur compounds, pesticides. Again, for my children and I, we had those boxes of things that had been treated with methyl bromide, causing the proteins in wool and leather to react, giving off a terrible stink of volatile sulphur compounds.
What else? Medicines? Hormones?
Of course there must be some a genetic vulnerabilities - hopefully DecodeME will find something. And of course the onset of ME/CFS seems to have something to do with infections of various pathogens.
But, all of us will have had multiple infections before the one that precipitated ME/CFS. For some of us, some of those infections will have been of the sort that are implicated in ME/CFS. So, what was it about the particular infection or the particular circumstances at the time that seems to have resulted in ME/CFS.
Or is it just random?
For example, some people are getting Long Covid on their third infection with SARS-CoV-2. Same genetics, same pathogen, different outcome. My daughter got ME/CFS after a viral infection, then recovered, and now she's had 3 Covid-19 rounds, and thankfully no return of symptoms.
Another example, I had ME/CFS for a year when I was ten, and recovered. When I was 17, I got shingles and EBV together - but I recovered quickly and easily, no ME/CFS. And then I got ME/CFS again after a viral infection when I was 47.
So, it's not just a simple equation of 'If genetics are vulnerable, and if there is an infection that causes ME/CFS, then ME/CFS'.
What other things do you think might be causing ME/CFS? What is the evidence for and against them? In my family, three of us got ME/CFS at the same time, so I have a bit of personal experience to triangulate against. I'm interested to hear your thoughts.
Over-exertion before/during the acute illness? Maybe, although I don't think that is a common factor.
Emotional stress? Again, maybe, although probably working via something like sleeplessness or smoking rate. But, I don't think it's a common factor, it wasn't for my children and I.
Hot weather or some other environmental factor like mould? I think we'd expect to see epidemics of ME/CFS, or geographic concentrations, and I don't think we have evidence of that. That said, has anyone been looking for that evidence? My children and I were in a brick house without AC for an extended heat wave, with a house full of newly delivered personal effects that had just been delivered after sitting in a container going mouldy in a tropical country, just before we got ME/CFS, so I could perhaps be persuaded about those factors.
Air pollutants e.g. sulphur compounds, pesticides. Again, for my children and I, we had those boxes of things that had been treated with methyl bromide, causing the proteins in wool and leather to react, giving off a terrible stink of volatile sulphur compounds.
What else? Medicines? Hormones?
Last edited: