Monica Greco (draft for 2017 paper) Pragmatics of explanation : creative accountability and ‘medically unexplained symptoms’

Monica Greco seems to do lots of uninteresting thoughtless work with long words on MUS. It's possibly worth reading her work to see how some people think about these things?

I don't know how I ended up being linked to this piece, but I thought that this paragraph was of interest, especially the anonymous quote in bold:

https://www.cbs.dk/files/cbs.dk/pragmatics_of_explanation_0.pdf

It looks like I was reading a draft version of this paper: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0081176917710425?journalCode=sora

 

Maybe if it's inconvenient that patients are leaving when they find out they have been lied to they should stop.

 

"but rather in terms of a pragmatic wager whose truth lies in the quality of its clinical effects.''

If the quality of clinical effects is good, and reported with objective truth there is less likely to be a problem; in a sense all medical treatment is a pragmatic wager. Oh, there's a problem there for the idea of MUS..

I do agree that 'they' should stop changing the names of this belief of theirs in an effort to confuse patients into compliance. Call a spade a spade - tell every MUS patient they have hysteria.

edit for tone and clarity - sorry @TiredSam

 

''In this reconfigured discursive space, the problem of explanation is recast not in terms of the need for a representational, objective truth on the basis of which treatment of one kind or another should follow, but rather in terms of a pragmatic wager whose truth lies in the quality of its clinical effects.''

Looks like the Patent Electric Circumlocution Enhancer has been at the brandy again.

 

I only read the abstract so cant comment on the full paper, but the abstract reminds me of some contemporary artists' 'Artist Statements'.
http://www.thecollectorsartist.com/pretentious-artists-statements-why-we-write-them/

https://artybollocks.com/#abg_full

When people use unnecessary highfalutin vocabulary like this i always think that the writer must feel terribly inadequate to feel such a need to make people impressed with them.

ETA link

 

haha brilliant

heres mine...
My work explores the relationship between Jungian archetypes and skateboard ethics.
With influences as diverse as Kafka and Frida Kahlo, new variations are generated from both mundane and transcendant textures.

Ever since I was a postgraduate I have been fascinated by the traditional understanding of the mind. What starts out as yearning soon becomes finessed into a carnival of distress, leaving only a sense of unreality and the unlikelihood of a new order.

As wavering derivatives become frozen through studious and personal practice, the viewer is left with an epitaph for the limits of our world.

Indeed

Actually replace one word & my statement was quite fitting really..... "What starts out as seeking help from a doctor for my devastating disease soon becomes finessed into a carnival of distress, leaving only a sense of unreality and the unlikelihood of a new order."

A 'carnival of distress' to which you Monica Greco are contributing when you write papers like these.