How I felt after 70 days of lying in bed for science (2015)

Dr Carrot

Dr Carrot

Senior Member (Voting Rights)
I recently re-read this piece and thought it was worth sharing based on the person’s experience of the effects of bed rest.

The key line, for me:

Within a few days of casual strolling and formal reconditioning exercise, my balance returned and my endurance began to recover. By the end of the two-week post–bed rest period, I felt 95 percent physically normal. I was ready to go.
Click to expand...

I suppose GET should be a miracle cure for those of us in bed rest then? Oh, wait. :unsure:

https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/jma83d/nasa-patient-8179-200
 
My experience was more like “after four months of no longer being completely bedbound my OI got a tiny bit better”, haha.

Overall, he paints a fairly accurate picture of the isolation and even all the things that can be missing in a relationship that is so close but just not possible, even if his perspective is that of an otherwise completely healthy person who did this of his own choice. And he doesn’t claim to have a perspective on being ill because of it, which I’m sure could be tempting to do.
 
Forbin said:
Well, if the person in this study could effectively recover from severe, enforced deconditioning in just a couple of weeks, I'd say the six month long PACE trial results pretty much prove that deconditioning is not the proximate cause of ME.
Click to expand...

Except that maybe all it shows is that deconditioning is not the proximate cause of inactivity in people who think they have ME but don't actually have it because all the people with real ME would not have volunteered to take part, having a false belief that they could not cope with GET. The only problem is that the theory was that people who only think they have ME are the ones who actually have ME (or CFS, this is a bit blurred). Now if even the people who just think they think they have ME but don't actually have a false belief they have ME don't get better ... (?) ... what hope is there for people who think they have ME and therefore do have ME? Or something like that. Whichever way up you turn it, the treatment doesn't work.
 
Jonathan Edwards said:
Except that maybe all it shows is that deconditioning is not the proximate cause of inactivity in people who think they have ME but don't actually have it because all the people with real ME would not have volunteered to take part, having a false belief that they could not cope with GET. The only problem is that the theory was that people who only think they have ME are the ones who actually have ME (or CFS, this is a bit blurred). Now if even the people who just think they think they have ME but don't actually have a false belief they have ME don't get better ... (?) ... what hope is there for people who think they have ME and therefore do have ME? Or something like that.
Click to expand...

My mind just imploded... :)

15116655_caa89981c4_z.jpg
 
Forbin said:
Well, if the person in this study could effectively recover from severe, enforced deconditioning in just a couple of weeks, I'd say the six month long PACE trial results pretty much prove that deconditioning is not the proximate cause of ME.
Click to expand...

In contrast, I was forced to undergo graded exercise for over 6 years by my employer's medical assessors (I was in the 'mild' category at the time) and all it did was make me worse.

White et al would probably say that I "did it wrong".
 
Dr Carrot said:
I recently re-read this piece and thought it was worth sharing based on the person’s experience of the effects of bed rest.

The key line, for me:



I suppose GET should be a miracle cure for those of us in bed rest then? Oh, wait. :unsure:

https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/jma83d/nasa-patient-8179-200
Click to expand...

The bed rest studies of the US and Chinese space programs more or less agree - healthy people recondition relatively quickly after prolonged bedrest...
 
The deconditioning theory of ME is nonsense.

I recovered fully and was able to hike 10 miles within a month of recovering fully from 6 months mostly bed bound with glandular fever many years before I got ME.

If my ME had been deconditioning, I would have recovered just as quickly and easily as I did after my glandular fever.
 
Not to mention the fact that many of us didn't know we had ME, didn't even know it existed, and still got sicker and sicker while trying to continue working out and staying active. I believed I wasn't being healthy enough for 8 years before I got so ill I was diagnosed. Which actually WAS a false illness belief, I believed I wasn't ill when I was. If I had believed I was ill at the time I probably never would have become severe or even moderate.
 
andypants said:
I believed I wasn't ill when I was. If I had believed I was ill at the time I probably never would have become severe or even moderate.
Click to expand...

That’s a good point to make when one of them throws that line at us, especially in the beginning.

They are often right that we do have false illness belief just the opposite version of the one they’re peddling.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom