Breathlessness and dysfunctional breathing in patients with [POTS]: The impact of a physiotherapy intervention, Reilly et al., 2020

[InitialConditions]

Postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) is a chronic, multifactorial syndrome with complex symptoms of orthostatic intolerance. Breathlessness is a prevalent symptom, however little is known about the aetiology. Anecdotal evidence suggests that breathless POTS patients commonly demonstrate dysfunctional breathing/hyperventilation syndrome (DB/HVS). There are, however, no published data regarding DB/HVS in POTS, and whether physiotherapy/breathing retraining may improve patients' breathing pattern and symptoms.

The aim of this study was to explore the potential impact of a physiotherapy intervention involving education and breathing control on DB/HVS in POTS. A retrospective observational cohort study of all patients with POTS referred to respiratory physiotherapy for treatment of DB/HVS over a 20-month period was undertaken.

100 patients (99 female, mean (standard deviation) age 31 (12) years) with a clinical diagnosis of DB/HV were referred, of which data was available for 66 patients pre – post intervention. Significant improvements in Nijmegen score, respiratory rate and breath hold time (seconds) were observed following treatment. These data provide a testable hypothesis that breathing retraining may provide breathless POTS patients with some symptomatic relief, thus improving their health-related quality of life. The intervention can be easily protocolised to ensure treatment fidelity. Our preliminary findings provide a platform for a subsequent randomised controlled trial of breathing retraining in POTS.

LINK

 

[Utsikt]

2.4 Physiotherapy treatment​

1.
The educational component of the intervention focused on the patient's understanding and consisted of:
I.
Respiratory physiology, specifically respiratory control and normal breathing pattern
II.
The mind – body link and how external factors such as anxiety, stress and lifestyle influences breathing patterns resulting in breathlessness (Spathis et al., 2017)
2.
The breathing re-training intervention

So a bit of breathing and a bit of psychobabble?

Fig. 2 Individual patient changes in (a) Nijmegen score, (b) respiratory rate and (c) breath hold time pre –post physiotherapy intervention. Each line represents an individual patient.

Can’t say this is looking very impressive.

The limitations section is unusually long, so props for that I guess. Although it begs the question of why they are providing this treatment without knowing if it actually does anything..

 

[rvallee]

Anecdotal evidence suggests that breathless POTS patients commonly demonstrate dysfunctional breathing/hyperventilation syndrome (DB/HVS).

No. Lots of health care professionals have been saying so, without any reason. Lots of people have been told by HCPs that they have this. So it's not based on the subjective experience of patients, it's just the opinions some professionals have decided was good enough an explanation for them to simply assert it as if it's a fact.

These data provide a testable hypothesis that breathing retraining may provide breathless POTS patients with some symptomatic relief, thus improving their health-related quality of life.

They do no such thing. What a bunch of crock.

As is the case with "Imagine a world"-based medicine, the conclusion was the starting point and evidence does not matter. Same old mindless junk where they explain something they don't even understand to people who don't even have the problems they made up.

Trials like this need to be banned. They don't even add any useful information and instead pollute the whole information space with junk. They're not even based on plausible mechanisms and even less so on anything validated. About all studies like this show is that breathing specialists can't tell the difference and are fine with making up retroactive explanations for things that don't even work.

The entire premise of "we will educate you about some things we know about how bodies work, and some other nonsensical bits tacked onto it" is clownish nonsense.