BBC radio programme on diagnostic names 12/07/2019

[JohnTheJack]

May be of interest:

Neurasthenia and homosexuality were both once classified as mental illness. Claudia reports on ever-changing labels and considers how today's diagnoses will be seen in the future.

On Radio 4.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0006n0s

 

[Cinders66]

May be of interest:



On Radio 4.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0006n0s

Looks interesting, separately neurasthenia and Simon wessely there

 

[Cinders66]

Mainly about safe to discuss historical diagnosis. Wessely got a lot of time to promote his theory on Shell shock. I thought there was recent research suggesting structural or functional brain change in shell shock but it didn’t cover that. Neurasthenia wasn’t connected to CFS at all and whilst the cultural explanations of neurasthenia were sort of laughed at, I personally don’t see much difference to Wesselys cultural explanation of shell shock and trauma or indeed CFS, what did he say once it was “the cultural metaphor or our time “ or something. Modern controversial diagnosis and classification such as CFS FM GWAS and ADHD , social anxiety, which some say are over diagnosed, weren’t discussed at all but would have been interesting.

 

[adambeyoncelowe]

Mainly about safe to discuss historical diagnosis. Wessely got a lot of time to promote his theory on Shell shock. I thought there was recent research suggesting structural or functional brain change in shell shock but it didn’t cover that. Neurasthenia wasn’t connected to CFS at all and whilst the cultural explanations of neurasthenia were sort of laughed at, I personally don’t see much difference to Wesselys cultural explanation of shell shock and trauma or indeed CFS, what did he say once it was “the cultural metaphor or our time “ or something. Modern controversial diagnosis and classification such as CFS FM GWAS and ADHD , social anxiety, which some say are over diagnosed, weren’t discussed at all but would have been interesting.

They were probably best left out.

 

[Cinders66]

They were probably best left out.

I’d quite like to hear open discussion on them tbh.

 

[adambeyoncelowe]

I’d quite like to hear open discussion on them tbh.

The issue is that this was a huge vehicle for Simon Wessely. There's no doubt in my mind he'd have got the last word.

 

[Cinders66]

The brain damage research on Shell shock

https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/06/blast-shock-tbi-ptsd-ied-shell-shock-world-war-one/

 

[MSEsperanza]

Episode 3: „What‘s in a Label?“, BBC Radio 4 (D for Diagnosis)

How accurate is a mental health diagnosis? Claudia Hammond reports on the value of a label and finds out why some mental health practitioners just refuse to give them.

Suzy built her life around a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, joining a support group, even writing a book about it, only to be given a completely different diagnosis not once, but twice. She lost her support group and a big part of her identity when her diagnosis was changed.

(ME / CFS not mentioned in the text, not able to listen))

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0006tyz

Producer: Fiona Hill