The Effect of Parenteral or Oral Iron Supplementation on Fatigue, Sleep, QoL & Restless Legs Syndrome in Iron-Deficient Blood Donors, 2020, Macher

Andy

Retired committee member
Full title: The Effect of Parenteral or Oral Iron Supplementation on Fatigue, Sleep, Quality of Life and Restless Legs Syndrome in Iron-Deficient Blood Donors: A Secondary Analysis of the IronWoMan RCT
Background: Besides anemia, iron deficiency may cause more subtle symptoms, including the restless legs syndrome (RLS), the chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) or sleeping disorders.

Objective: The aim of this pre-planned secondary analysis of the IronWoMan randomized controlled trial (RCT) was to compare the frequency and severity of symptoms associated with iron deficiency before and after (intravenous or oral) iron supplementation in iron deficient blood donors.

Methods/Design: Prospective, randomized, controlled, single-centre trial. (ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT01787526). Setting: Tertiary care center in Graz, Austria. Participants: 176 (138 female and 38 male) whole-blood and platelet apheresis donors aged ≥ 18 and ≤ 65 years with iron deficiency (ferritin ≤ 30ng/mL at the time of blood donation). Interventions: Intravenous iron (1 g ferric carboxymaltose, n = 86) or oral iron supplementation (10 g iron fumarate, 100 capsules, n = 90). Measurements: Clinical symptoms were evaluated by a survey before iron therapy (visit 0, V0) and after 8–12 weeks (visit 1, V1), including questions about symptoms of restless legs syndrome (RLS), chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), sleeping disorders, quality of life and symptoms like headaches, dyspnoea, dizziness, palpitations, pica and trophic changes in fingernails or hair.

Results: We found a significant improvement in the severity of symptoms for RLS, fatigue and sleep quality (p < 0.001). Furthermore, a significant decrease in headaches, dyspnoea, dizziness and palpitations was reported (p < 0.05). There was no difference between the type of iron supplementation (intravenous versus oral) and clinical outcome data.

Conclusion: Iron supplementation in iron-deficient blood donors may be an effective strategy to improve symptoms related to iron deficiency and the wellbeing of blood donors.
Open access, https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/12/5/1313/htm

While they talk of "the chronic fatigue syndrome", the criteria that they use to determine if someone has it is
Fatigue: Based on the Multidimensional Fatigue Symptom Inventory (MFSI) [36], five different scales (general, physical, emotional, mental, vigor) were evaluated in the questionnaire.
 
Background: Besides anemia, iron deficiency may cause more subtle symptoms, including the restless legs syndrome (RLS), the chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) or sleeping disorders.
That looks like they mean the symptom 'chronic fatigue', not CFS. Anaemia is well known to cause CF. I've never heard of it causing CFS.
 
That looks like they mean the symptom 'chronic fatigue', not CFS. Anaemia is well known to cause CF. I've never heard of it causing CFS.
People still talk about the disaster of one of the Mars landers crashing on the surface because one team worked in metric while the other worked in imperial units. What a dumb failure that was. Never happened again, though. Because the aerospace profession learn from their failures.

This failure of basic vocabulary in medicine is so much worse than this and it is chronic, systemic. Words have meaning, dammit. There is a lot of discussion over the lack of "soft" skills in STEM but frankly this applies every bit as much to medicine. Being so bad at communicating is simply unjustifiable in this day and age. What a mess.
 
Conclusion: Iron supplementation in iron-deficient blood donors may be an effective strategy to improve symptoms related to iron deficiency and the wellbeing of blood donors.

This seems less than groundbreaking. Do oxygen deficient patients feel better when given oxygen or do dehydrated patients feel better when given water? I could keep graduate students going for years with these.
 
there have been many studies about iron supplements the last one I vaguely remember mentioned that many patients have adverse effects especially from intravenous iron then of course those who have any kind of digestive issues are not going to receive beneficial doses from over the counter iron pills my anaemia has worsened over the years but my doctors do not recommend anything other than shop bought iron pills .
 
Back
Top Bottom