Search results

  1. Jonathan Edwards

    [BBC News] Exercise is good for joints with wear-and-tear arthritis

    I have not looked at this in detail but I have a strong sense that this draft guideline is CRAP. That statement about synovial fluid is pure bullshit. We know absolutely nothing about any beneficial effects of exercise mediated by changes in synovial fluid. It is just made up pseudo physiology...
  2. Jonathan Edwards

    Elevated ATG13 in serum of pwME stimulates oxidative stress response in microglial cells , 2022, Gottschalk et al

    You don't 'simply put a value' because a machine generates it. You need to know what the machine reading means.
  3. Jonathan Edwards

    Elevated ATG13 in serum of pwME stimulates oxidative stress response in microglial cells , 2022, Gottschalk et al

    Thanks. That seems a pretty bizarre way to present data of this sort. Not sure what negative concentrations are supposed to be!
  4. Jonathan Edwards

    Elevated ATG13 in serum of pwME stimulates oxidative stress response in microglial cells , 2022, Gottschalk et al

    Unless people are prepared to put some actual data in the abstract I am unenthusiastic about trying to wade through. I seem to be able to access a half paper with some 'snippets'. It all seems like deliberate obfuscation purely for the benefit of those making money out of the publication...
  5. Jonathan Edwards

    A general thread on the PACE trial!

    I cannot access Twitter threads these days. I get blocked from moving from the first shot.
  6. Jonathan Edwards

    A general thread on the PACE trial!

    It struck me more than once that there's a further problem if self-reporting: it’s hard to report that the nice people trying to help have been useless. Is this effectively controlled for? A simple piece of psychology that makes sense to most people - except, it seems, psychologists.
  7. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    Looking at Webster's Medical Dictionary on Fatigue: 1: weariness or exhaustion from labor, exertion, or stress 2: the temporary loss of power to respond induced in a sensory receptor or motor end organ by continued stimulation So that is not the professional meaning. The professional isn't...
  8. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    I think medical dictionary definitions need to be distinguished from how medics actually use terms professionally. Medical dictionaries are probably mostly intended for lay people. As far as I know doctors never use them. The definitions are probably coloured by a desire to be widely...
  9. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    That looks like the sort of vague dumbed down definition that seems now to be very prevalent on internet information sources. Maybe everything is like that in the internet age now but I find it hard to see what better term to use. Moreover, when used as part of the specific triplet PEM there is...
  10. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    That seems to me to be an insult to those physicians like Jason and Nacul who are trying their best to provide a usable framework for discussing ME. If patients aren't prepared to give credit where due then they are likely to find themselves completely alone.
  11. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    Where does that definition come from? It is completely inappropriate and I have never heard anything like it before. Malaise is normally used when you know that the cause is likely to be an infection.
  12. Jonathan Edwards

    Exercise Training in Post-COVID-19 Patients: The Need for a Multifactorial Protocol for a Multifactorial Pathophysiology, 2022, Cattadori et al

    I was lucky enough to work for the NHS all my life and never needed a sick note. The people who needed to organise cover for me accepted that I was sick.
  13. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    As far as I am aware physicians that use the term use it in that way. They understand that patients feel unwell with discomfort or frank pain all over. Malaise in the context of typhoid or viral illness is not anything trivial. The medical professionals who don't believe PWME really have bad...
  14. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    I was taught the meaning of the word by my parents, who were both physicians. Malaise is used in social contexts but lots of medical terms are. I really don't know what baggage you are talking about.
  15. Jonathan Edwards

    The '25% have severe ME' statistic

    Is this worth trying to justify? Since we know that ascertainment and variation in criteria make it pretty impossible to give a prevalence accurate to better than a factor of two and grading severity is full of caveats all we can usefully say is that a substantial minority are severely affected...
  16. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    Arthralgia and myalgia are too specific. It isn't clear that the symptoms are coming from these structures. In polymyalgia rheumatic, for instance, the 'myalgia' is probably coming from perimysial fascia and ligament. Malaise is a more appropriate term for a more generalised sense of being...
  17. Jonathan Edwards

    “Dr. Ken Friedman and Dr. David Maughan – ME/CFS and Long Haul Covid Similarities and Ramifications” podcast

    That is pretty much what malaise means in medical terminology. It is what people with prostrating infective illness like typhoid have - very much involving joint and muscle pain. __________________ This post has been copied and following discussion moved to this thread: Meaning of the word...
  18. Jonathan Edwards

    Meaning of the word 'malaise' and its use in the term Post-exertional malaise (PEM)

    This post has been copied and following discussion moved from this thread: “Dr. Ken Friedman and Dr. David Maughan – ME/CFS and Long Haul Covid Similarities and Ramifications” podcast That is pretty much what malaise means in medical terminology. It is what people with prostrating infective...
  19. Jonathan Edwards

    Exercise Training in Post-COVID-19 Patients: The Need for a Multifactorial Protocol for a Multifactorial Pathophysiology, 2022, Cattadori et al

    Well I've been listening to you guys with ME for 8 years now and what I have had seems to have the same basic pattern. It is also reminiscent of what I had 50 years ago 6 months after EBV. As I indicated I don't think I have ME, but equally I do not have cardiac or lung disease. There is a...
Back
Top