Search results

  1. Jonathan Edwards

    Experiences of a cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) intervention for fatigue in patients receiving haemodialysis, 2022, Picariello, Moss-Morris et al

    We tried to do a trial of CBT (whatever that means in this instance) in renal fatigue but the patients thought we were stupid nosy-parkers. In the end some of them just about put up with us and our dumb theories - or pretended to. The results are consistent with the fact that nothing actually...
  2. Jonathan Edwards

    The biological challenge of myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: a solvable problem (2016), Edwards, JC et al

    The prevalence figure if I remember rightly was intended to refer to multiple sclerosis, diabetes and RA, hence no citation, but I agree it is ambiguous. I agree that 0.2% prevalence is probably the most realistic figure but I disagree that broad criteria necessarily lead to bad research. It...
  3. Jonathan Edwards

    FII and Perplexing Presentations: What is the Evidence Base for and against Current Guidelines, and What..., 2022, Gullon-Scott and Long

    It is interesting to see people so ignorant. Science and evidence are two quite different concepts. My first degree was in Art History. Art History makes better use of evidence than medicine but that does not make it a science. It just makes it reliable - which is important for those investing...
  4. Jonathan Edwards

    Should Burnout Be Conceptualized as a Mental Disorder?, 2022, Nadon et al

    I had burnout after four years of more or less single-handed development of a drug treatment that I knew might kill some of my favourite people. It probably did kill one. In the photos of me at the end I look about 101. I have always thought of my mental state as entirely normal.
  5. Jonathan Edwards

    FII and Perplexing Presentations: What is the Evidence Base for and against Current Guidelines, and What..., 2022, Gullon-Scott and Long

    Sorry, but I disagree. The geneticists have a clear understanding of EDS which has been completely messed up by practitioners who should know better - very often with private practices but also pseudo-academic empires. The genetics of EDS have been subject to extensive research. The problem has...
  6. Jonathan Edwards

    Development of an inpatient rehabilitation pathway for motor functional neurological disorders: Initial reflections, 2022, Polich, Perez, Baslet et al

    I agree. But maybe 'meaning well' is only an excuse if it includes the humility needed to know when you don't know whether what you are doing will be helpful.
  7. Jonathan Edwards

    EDS, hypermobility, and the link, if any, to ME/CFS

    As far as I can see this is Dr J Tanner of Oving Clinic saying 'patients are very confused about CCI and to be honest I am pretty confused and cannot work out well enough what is what to give any useful information but my course of 3-4 injections could be good'. Dr Tanner is an osteopath
  8. Jonathan Edwards

    Eye movements may be key to chronic fatigue syndrome diagnosis

    Behaviour can be reflex. I think this is the sort of talk that derives from the behaviourist approach - which basically denies the existence of the 'mental' other than in terms of input and output. Behaviour is any output you can measure.
  9. Jonathan Edwards

    UK: NIHR funding opportunity: 22/37 Non-pharmacological interventions for fatigue management in adults with long-term health conditions

    The approach is just plain stupid. If you ask for people who are interested in doing a review of the effectiveness of X you will get applications from people who have a vested interest in showing the effectiveness of X. Anyone with a reasonable degree of scepticism and at least minimal knowledge...
  10. Jonathan Edwards

    Incidence of Lyme disease in the United Kingdom and association with fatigue: A population-based, historical cohort study, 2022, Brellier, Nacul et al

    The two are not necessarily alternatives, just different ways of categorising illness. Atherosclerosis and myocardial infarction can apply to the same person - they nearly always do.
  11. Jonathan Edwards

    ‘We suppressed our scientific imagination’: four experts examine the big successes and failures of the COVID response so far

    All fair enough but I don't suppose anyone mentioned the likelihood that the pandemic itself was the results of such collaboration. Even if it wasn't, we know that practices were sufficiently lax for it to have been a real possibility. The negligence of the scientific community is unarguable...
  12. Jonathan Edwards

    ‘We suppressed our scientific imagination’: four experts examine the big successes and failures of the COVID response so far

    Twaddle from Greenhalgh as usual. Any idiot knew it was sensible to wear a mask.
  13. Jonathan Edwards

    Genetic association study in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) identifies several potential risk loci, 2022,Hajdarevic et al

    Who knows? - we would need to find out. Maybe that the critical abnormal process in ME is so hard to observe because it involves supramolecular solid phase changes within brain cells at a level that at present we have no means to observe directly?
  14. Jonathan Edwards

    United Kingdom: Action for ME (AfME) news

    That sounds an odd sort of job for a charity of this sort. Research directors work in academic units as a rule. Large charities do have people to supervise allocation of research funds but it isn't clear that this is what this job is.
  15. Jonathan Edwards

    Genetic association study in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) identifies several potential risk loci, 2022,Hajdarevic et al

    I don't think anyone was saying that this SNP would account for most ME. I see it as a bit like C1q deficiency, which accounts for a tiny proportion of cases of lupus but provides a hugely powerful piece of evidence for the importance of complement in the genesis of lupus. It turns out that...
  16. Jonathan Edwards

    Implementation statement in support of ME/CFS diagnosis and management, NICE, draft published for consultation

    It almost certainly is. However, since the NHS at present couldn't implement an extended session of imbibition of alcohol in a fermentation plant I cannot see the point of any of that verbiage.
  17. Jonathan Edwards

    Genetic association study in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) identifies several potential risk loci, 2022,Hajdarevic et al

    There is bound to be a way to fit it in but the question is whether it adds a further 'aha' to the story. I am a bit preoccupied with other things today but will come back to this. It is only a speculation but it has some theoretical attractions.
Back
Top Bottom