Quite apart from all the important (and valid) study-design and statistical issues raised above, the comment that really stands out for me is:
The media hype is staggeringly inappropriate.
What do we think of the "Fatigue Severity Scale"? It seemingly was constucted by some doctors in 1989 to track/diagnose MS and SLE. To equally weight 9 questions like "1. My motivation is lower when I am fatigued. 2. Exercise brings on my fatigue. 3. I am easily fatigued. " seems not very...
The EndoPAT device seems to no longer be in production, and this 2012 paper had doubts about what it was actually measuring (although perhaps they addressed issues for the thread paper)
In any case, I agree with:
Similarities with tinnitus, where (in the most common pathway) loss of afferent signals (caused by damaged hair cells for some frequencies) encourage auditory pathway neurons that normally process these frequencies, and/or neighboring cells alert to this lack of signalling, may spontaneously...
Would you be able to answer my earlier question to Prof Ponting:
This non-scientist's understanding would benefit from knowing the variables involved in the gene-set analyses:
Z = B0 + C1.B1 + ... + CnBn + e
... is Z the 13 gene-analysis ones, or is it all 18k?
... is C1 a binary 0/1 for...
Great @Andy - thanks so much - this non-scientist has been toiling over the MAGMA analysis. The paper above is really good and this post and another from @forestglip really nails it.
Thanks so much. Presumably the vast non-coding genome regions would contain very few of the study's GWAS genotyped markers, so that the "Phasing and genotype imputation" genotyping steps would not not impute anything statistically reliable.
How are we to reconcile the somewhat different genes and tissues of:
Fig. 3. MAGMA gene-tissue analysis shows statistically significant enrichment of ME/CFS-related genes in all 13 brain tissues.
Fig. 4: Approximate Bayes factor posterior probability (PPH4) that mRNA expression and ME/CFS...
You are (way) ahead of me - I was reading the original 2015 MAGMA paper where the gene-set variables are just 0/1 although those authors point out "The variables C1, C2, . . ., in this generalized gene-set analysis model can reflect any gene property, from the binary indicators used for the...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.